Pinned valuation:
I have revisited JIN since @Rick mentioned it in response to one of my posts.
I came up with a positive valuation, which I've gone with against my normally pessimistic tendencies, of $9.08. That is off the back of using the McNiven Formula.
More conservative Valuations give me $6.17 (increased risk premium - 12% required return instead of 10%), $5.00 (as previous but with a ROE reduced from 37% to 30%) and $4.93 (37% ROE and 15% return).
My worst valuation is just my Dividends before Franking Credit Calculation - which is 6% of the share price on anticipated forward dividends. That for JIN is $4 per share based on 24 cents per share dividend.
In the latest half-year results Management revised the target payout ratio DOWN to 30-50% of NPAT from 65-85%. Now as an investor I HATE that, but at least on this occasion it is prioritising debt repayment which along with the UK expansion should strengthen the company overall. I think it WILL hurt the share price in the interim though, as it is much less attractive for those (like me) with a dividend focus.
Most of the half year results seemed pretty positive, hopefully indicating growth, but how much and over how long remains to be seen.


Despite this, I decided to take a small 'watch position' (already down over 5% - so not a promising start), and give it the positive valuation as a mindset exercise. Lets see how we go.
As I type this on 12 May 2026 the price is $7.23.
@tomsmithidg welcome aboard and thank you for your valuations. I had a quick check of my current valuation ($12) and I’m happy to leave it where it is for now (based on a required 13% return).
At $9.00 per share I would be expecting a 15% annual return, which is a nice entry point for a quality business. This puts Jumbo on a FY26 PE of 13. Currently I believe it’s trading on a FY26 PE of 10. Not bad for a business with metrics like this.
I am very perplexed about the falling share price. I continued to add today, including in after close trading ($7.18). I think this business is an absolute bargain now. At $7.18 I have it returning $17.5% (using McNiven’s formula).
Of course this is all based on a number of assumptions about the future. If my assumptions are BS, then my valuation is also BS and I lose a lot of cash! Here are my assumptions:
For FY26 I’m working on consensus revenue and NPAT, and then calculating the other metrics accordingly;
Here is the current consensus (Simply Wall Street, 4 analysts)


Here is past performance (CommSec)

I don’t see any signs of ROE falling below 30% over the next few years. The other consideration that is making Jumbo more valuable is the change to the dividend policy (reduced to 30% -50% payout ratio). Most investors see this as a negative. However, reinvesting earnings into the business when ROE is over 30% is excellent use of capital (see diagram below).

Either the market or the analysts have Jumbo wrong. We’re in the middle of confession season, so I don’t think we’ll have to wait long to find out!
Held IRL and accumulating (2.5%)