Top member reports
Consensus community valuation
$2.98
Average Intrinsic Value
23.1%
Undervalued by
Active Member Straws
#Reports & Presentations
Added 2 weeks ago

24-7-2020:  WSA Quarterly Activities Report

WESTERN AREAS FINISHES FY20 IN STRONG POSITION – STRATEGICALLY SET FOR LONG TERM NICKEL PRODUCTION

Western Areas (ASX: WSA) is pleased to provide the June Quarterly Activity report.

JUNE QUARTER 2020 HIGHLIGHTS: 

  • Odysseus underground mine development preparing for fresh decline take-off toward the Odysseus deposit
  • Strategic 19.9% investment in Panoramic Resources Ltd completed for A$28.6m
  • Exploration success at Western Gawler has the potential to unlock a new base metal province
  • Forrestania and Cosmos operations continue materially unaffected by Covid-19
  • Nickel production contained in ore mined of 5,841 tonnes. FY20 total of 23,391 tonnes
  • Mill production of 5,114 nickel tonnes in concentrate. FY20 total of 20,926 tonnes (99.7% of guidance)
  • Unit cash cost of nickel in concentrate of A$3.23/lb. FY20 total A$3.13/lb, reporting at the mid-point of guidance
  • Operating cashflow of A$22.9m with cash at bank of A$144.8m and no debt
  • Cash plus receivables and liquid assets of $190.6m (Mar Q A$193.3m)

Western Areas Managing Director, Mr Dan Lougher, said it has been a busy quarter at Western Areas across many fronts, including exploration, project development and operations, while also advancing and building long term strategic optionality into the Company via an investment in Panoramic Resources.

"Pleasingly our assets continued to operate reliably and consistently, enabling the Company to materially deliver into all FY20 guidance metrics, acknowledging a slight shortfall in nickel concentrate production, achieving 99.7% of guided production range.

Most encouragingly during the quarter, our systematic and sustained exploration effort at the West Gawler Project in South Australia has started to show its potential as a new base metal region, with the first diamond drill hole at the Sahara target area intersecting a significant interval of mineralisation,” Mr Lougher said.

--- click on link above for the full report --- [the above is just the first bit]

[I hold WSA shares]

Also:  (today, 24-7-2020):  Assays Confirm Nickel and Copper Sulphide at Sahara

And one month ago (23-6-2020):  Western Gawler Drilling Strikes Significant Nickel & Copper

Plus:  23-7-2020:  SGQ: Mt Alexander - Drilling Update

[WSA owns 25% of the tenements and the minerals contained within them - that St George Mining - SGQ - is discussing in that announcement]

Also:  19-6-2020:  Western Areas takes 19.9% Stake in Panoramic Resources (PAN)

Read More
#Drilling/Assay Results
Added a month ago
Read More
#Broker/Analyst Views
Last edited 3 months ago

27-Apr-2020:  5 Brokers have upgraded their calls on WSA this morning (or over the weekend):

Citi rates WSA as a Buy 

March quarter production was in line with expectations. Western Areas offers leverage to nickel, which Citi expects will recover in the second half.

While there are delays to equipment, Odysseus remains on time for first production in late 2022.

Cosmos should also add to output and maintain the production pipeline as Forrestania winds down, the broker notes. Buy rating retained. Target is reduced to $2.50 from $2.85.

Target Price (TP) is $2.50 Current Price is $2.10 Difference: $0.40

Forecasts:

  • Citi forecasts a full year FY20 dividend of 3.00 cents and EPS of 16.30 cents.
  • At the last closing share price the estimated dividend yield is 1.43%.
  • At the last closing share price the stock's estimated Price to Earnings Ratio (PER) is 12.88.
  • Citi forecasts a full year FY21 dividend of 2.00 cents and EPS of 16.80 cents.

-------

Credit Suisse rates WSA as Neutral 

Credit Suisse assesses Western Areas is on track for FY20 guidance from both a production and cost perspective. A decline in spot nickel suggests margin compression in the June quarter.

There has been some delay to infrastructure sourced from South Africa because of the pandemic but this is not expected to impact the timing of the Odysseus project. Neutral rating retained. Target is reduced to $2.35 from $2.50.

TP is $2.35 Current Price is $2.10 Difference: $0.25

Forecasts:

  • Credit Suisse forecasts a full year FY20 dividend of 3.00 cents and EPS of 17.67 cents.
  • At the last closing share price the estimated dividend yield is 1.43%.
  • At the last closing share price the stock's estimated Price to Earnings Ratio (PER) is 11.88.
  • Credit Suisse forecasts a full year FY21 dividend of 3.35 cents and EPS of 11.17 cents.

-------

Macquarie rates WSA as Outperform 

Western Areas March quarter result was mixed, the broker suggests, but FY guidance remains unchanged and cash flow was better than expected.

Development work at Cosmos is proceeding and work on the Flying Fox mine plan could result in a one-year mine life extension, the broker notes.

The broker retains Outperform, while acknowledging downside risk at current nickel spot prices. Target falls to $2.90 from $3.50.

TP is $2.90 Current Price is $2.10 Difference: $0.80

Forecasts:

  • Macquarie forecasts a full year FY20 dividend of 1.00 cents and EPS of 9.60 cents.
  • At the last closing share price the estimated dividend yield is 0.48%.
  • At the last closing share price the stock's estimated Price to Earnings Ratio (PER) is 21.88.
  • Macquarie forecasts a full year FY21 dividend of 5.00 cents and EPS of 31.30 cents.

-------

Morgan Stanley rates WSA as Overweight

Western Areas is expected to meet guidance in FY20. The lock-down in South Africa, if extended, may delay the delivery of key equipment to Odysseus but, overall, no delay to the project is expected.

Morgan Stanley retains an Overweight rating, In-Line industry view and $2.60 target.

TP is $2.60 Current Price is $2.10 Difference: $0.50

Forecasts:

  • Morgan Stanley forecasts a full year FY20 dividend of 5.00 cents and EPS of 22.00 cents.
  • At the last closing share price the estimated dividend yield is 2.38%.
  • At the last closing share price the stock's estimated Price to Earnings Ratio (PER) is 9.55.
  • Morgan Stanley forecasts a full year FY21 div of 3.00 cents and EPS of 13.00 cents.

-------

UBS rates WSA as a Buy

UBS considers the quarterly result was generally in line with market expectations. However, production guidance of 21-22,000tpa implies the lower end of guidance will be attained rather than the top.

The broker retains a Buy rating and $2.50 target, noting the share price is trading at a -15% discount to valuation.

The business is highly leveraged to the nickel price which faces downside risks over the short term because of a lack of demand globally for stainless steel.

TP is $2.50 Current Price is $2.10 Difference: $0.40

Forecasts:

  • UBS forecasts a full year FY20 dividend of 1.00 cents and EPS of 13.00 cents.
  • At the last closing share price the estimated dividend yield is 0.48%.
  • At the last closing share price the stock's estimated Price to Earnings Ratio (PER) is 16.15.
  • UBS forecasts a full year FY21 dividend of 3.00 cents and EPS of 17.00 cents.

-------

CONSENSUS Forecast for FY20:

  • Current consensus EPS estimate is 18.2, implying annual growth of 250.7%.
  • Current consensus DPS estimate is 2.5, implying a prospective dividend yield of 1.2%.
  • Current consensus EPS estimate suggests the PER is 11.5.

CONSENSUS Forecast for FY21:

  • Current consensus EPS estimate is 18.0, implying annual growth of -1.1%.
  • Current consensus DPS estimate is 3.1, implying a prospective dividend yield of 1.5%.
  • Current consensus EPS estimate suggests the PER is 11.7.

From:

  1. Macquarie (27 Apr: Outperform: $2.90)
  2. Citi (27 Apr: Buy: $2.50)
  3. UBS (27 Apr: Buy: $2.50)
  4. Credit Suisse (27 Apr: Neutral: $2.35)
  5. Morgan Stanley (27 Apr: Overweight: $2.60)
  6. Ord Minnett (13 Mar: Buy: $2.50)
  7. Morgans (29 Jan: Add: $3.23)

--------------

Disclosure:  I hold WSA shares.

Read More
#Bull Case
Last edited 3 months ago

September 2019 (?) I think...  Western Areas (WSA) is one of a small number of pure nickel plays on the ASX, and probably the most prominent one.  Nickel prices have been rising since December (up around 20% over the past 3 months).  I don't have a view on the company specifically in terms of management, balance sheet, etc., but purely as a nickel play, it would be one of the more obvious ones.  Warehouse levels are falling.  The price is rising.  The perception of future demand is that we are going to need more nickel for EV and other batteries to store energy.  There are not currently many new nickel mines that have been approved for development and construction.  WSA is a smaller company, and doesn't get much attention, but if nickel goes for a run, they will get a lot more.  They are a producer now, not an explorer or a developer, so they get the full benefits of a rising price as it happens.  They also have two of the highest grade operating nickel mines in the world in Flying Fox and Spotted Quoll (at Forrestania in WA) - see here:  http://www.westernareas.com.au/operations/forrestania-australia.html

22-Apr-2020:  Nickel prices are smashed now - they've been coronered along with all base metal prices - and I reckon copper will turn positive first, and then nickel will follow, so I'm not actually holding any WSA currently.  I do hold Sandfire (copper) (SFR) and I'll probably buy IGO & WSA when copper heads north again and nickel follows.  I think IGO and WSA are the best nickel plays on the ASX.  I also still hold S32, who do produce some nickel, but I hold them on a valuation basis - coz they look cheap - and they're reasonably diversified across alumina/aluminium, met coal, nickel, zinc, lead, silver and manganese.  I don't mind holding them through the cycle, and SFR, but a pure nickel play like WSA is a little riskier when the global growth outlook is so negative.

Read More
#Reports & Presentations
Added 3 months ago
Read More
#Reports & Presentations
Last edited 6 months ago
Read More
#Reports & Presentations
Last edited 6 months ago
Read More
#New Offtake Agreement
Last edited 7 months ago
Read More
#Reports & Presentations
Last edited 7 months ago
Read More
#ASX Announcements
Last edited 7 months ago

05-Jul-19:  Odysseus Early Works Completed On Time and Budget

WSA finished the day up +4.64%.

Disclosure:  I hold about $10K worth of WSA.  They produce high grade ("battery class") nickel, and their costs are reasonable.  They are well run but you still have to be bullish on nickel to own WSA (and I am).

Read More
#Bull Case
Last edited 8 months ago

May 2019:  This is the bull case for WSA from WSA (i.e. in their own words, taken from a recent quarterly report):

Western Areas has Australia’s highest grade nickel mines and is a low unit cash cost producer.  Its main asset, the 100% owned Forrestania Nickel Project, is located 400km east of Perth in Western Australia.  Western Areas is also Australia’s second largest independent sulphide nickel miner producing approximately 22,000 to 25,000 nickel  tonnes in ore per annum from its Flying Fox and Spotted Quoll mines - two of the lowest cost and highest grade nickel operations in the world.  

An active nickel project developer at Cosmos and explorer at Western Gawler in Australia, the Company also holds exploration interests in Canada through shareholdings in Grid Metals (formerly Mustang Minerals). Additionally, the Company has exposure to the emerging lithium market via its shareholding in Kidman Resources Limited.  

The Board remains focused on the core business of low cost, long life nickel production, new nickel discoveries and  generating returns to shareholders. It has put in place the cost structure and capabilities to prosper throughout the cycle by adopting prudent capital management and an opportunistic approach.  Its latest presentation can be found at  http://www.westernareas.com.au/investor-centre/corporate-presentations.html

 

--- ends ---

That was taken from their March Quarter Activities Report.

 

Disclosure:  I hold WSA shares.  I bought some more yesterday (27th May 2019) after the nickel price rose again.  Because they are a single commodity producer, you would need to be bullish on nickel, because if nickel goes down, so do they, but if you like the exposure to nickel, they're a good company within that space. 

Additional:  Matt Haupt, the lead PM for WLE (WAM Leaders Fund) holds WSA in WLE.  He also holds IGO (as I do).  He also holds Oz Minerals (OZL) among the smaller miners, as well as the usual suspects - the big names like BHP, RIO & S32.  OZL are a copper miner mostly - which I don't hold.  My preferred copper exposure is via Sandfire (SFR, copper & gold) and Independence Group (IGO, nickel, copper, gold, cobalt).  I do hold S32, but not BHP or RIO currently.   I think the time to buy / hold iron ore miners is when the iron ore price is low, not when it's high - like it is now.  And the best exposure to iron ore on our market - when the price is high - is via FMG, which, again, is best bought when the iron ore price is low.  BHP is up a lot this year, RIO and FMG are up even more, within a couple of percentage points of their 12 month highs.  WSA on the other hand is well down on where they were a year ago, and that makes them a lot more interesting to me.  They're smaller, riskier, and leveraged to a single commodity but it's a commodity I'm comfortable with exposure to, and that's why I've recently (yesterday) topped up my WSA shareholding.

Read More
#Media Articles
Last edited 9 months ago

April 29 2019:  From MNN: MiningNews.Net.  Reporter: Michael Quinn.

Western Areas delivers as planned

CONSISTENTLY well-performed nickel miner Western Areas looks to have delivered another bog standard quarter in the March period, with all key operational metrics broadly in line with previous quarters.

Arguably the highlight was the cash cost of the 5548 tonnes of nickel in concentrate of US$2.01 per pound, the lowest achieved in the current financial year, while cash at bank at quarter's end of A$116.7 million was down on December's $134.3 million after customer payments totalling $10.3 million were received on April 1.

Cash at bank plus nickel sales receivables gained $2.5 million quarter on quarter to $149.9 million.

Growth expenditure for the next addition to the Western Areas' stable, the Odysseus project at Cosmos, totalled $6.6 million, with the majority of the expenditure relating to the ongoing underground decline rehabilitation works, underground dewatering and the shaft haulage system detailed design and relocation.  

Meanwhile the company spent $2.7 million on exploration and flagged the emergence of the Mystic prospect in South Australia's Western Gawler "following the identification of elevated nickel in oxide mineralisation" - first reported in the September 2018 quarter.

"The corridor is broadly defined as 300m wide and 400m along strike, open to both the north and south," Western Areas said.

"Further aircore drilling is planned to extend drilling coverage and evaluate the economic potential of this zone in the second half of 2019."

Western Areas said it was "particularly encouraged by these result as they represent the highest?grade nickel mineralisation identified to date across the Fowler Domain of the Western Gawler project".

Western Areas' ground lies east and south of the Jacinth mineral sands operation. [JC's note: Jacinth is operated by Iluka: ASX:ILU]

Shares in Western Areas were unchanged at $2.34 in afternoon trade, capitalising the company at $640 million.

The stock was at levels around 30% higher 12 months ago.

--- ends ---

21-May-2019:  WSA is now $2.22, 12c (or 5%) lower than they were when Michael Quinn penned that piece three weeks ago.  Base metals were lower overnight and it would seem the demand for nickel - and copper in particular - is not as strong as some had been predicting.  There is certainly scope for base metal prices to move lower in the short term, but medium to longer term I think they're going higher, especially if a trade deal is inked between the US and China.  The main risk with WSA is that they are a single commodity miner (nickel) and so their fortunes are always going to be very strongly tied to the nickel price.  Their main advantage is their cost advantage.  They have a couple of high grade and low cost nickel mines.  If you want to play nickel, my picks in the sector are WSA & IGO, but you would need to be bullish on nickel first.

Read More
#Reports & Presentations
Last edited 9 months ago

29-April-2019:  Western Areas have this morning released their March 2019 Quarter Activity Report.

March Quarter 2019 Highlights:

  • Lowest quarterly cash cost for the year, unit cash cost of nickel in concentrate of A$2.82/lb and A$2.98 YTD
  • Mine production of 6,066 nickel tonnes and 17,785 nickel tonnes YTD
  • Mill production of 5,448 nickel tonnes and 16,242 nickel tonnes YTD, highest quarterly production YTD
  • Cash at bank plus nickel sales receivables increased to A$149.9m (December quarter A$143.8m)
  • Stronger nickel price for the quarter (A$8.31) with $10.3m cash receipted on 1 April resulting in higher sales receivable balance at quarter end
  • Odysseus underground development advancing well, dewatering and decline rehabilitation progressing as planned

Western Areas Managing Director, Mr Dan Lougher, said the March quarter was another consistent performance in line with plan across the operations.

“Pleasingly the March quarter result was the lowest cash cost of production of nickel into concentrate for the year.”

“It is also very exciting to see the decline rehabilitation start at the Odysseus mine, our next long life project that will underpin the future of Western Areas.”

Read More