Forum Topics Market - Macro
Hackenbacker
Added 4 years ago

The global pandemic has catalysed remarkable shifts in the Australian housing market. From the temporary shutdown of cities, to an unprecedented monetary policy strategy, a new-found popularity of regional and low-density housing preferences and the introduction of various government home buying incentives, the COVID-period has had distinct impacts on the composition of buyers and the dynamics of the housing market. 

Here I explore six of the major impacts on the Australian housing market two years on.

1. Australian home values rose 25%, to record highs.

Despite an initial dip, housing values rose 24.6% between the end of March 2020 and February 2022. Figure 1.0 shows the cumulative change in the national CoreLogic Home Value Index since the onset of COVID-19. The index had a relatively small decline at the onset of COVID-19, with sales and listings volumes being far more impacted than prices. National home values declined -2.1% between April 2020 and September 2020, before soaring amid low interest rates, high household savings, government grants and a sharp reduction in the supply of housing. 

By February 2022, CoreLogic estimated the total value of residential real estate to be $9.8 trillion, up from $7.2 trillion at the onset of the pandemic. The median Australian dwelling value increased $173,805, to $728,034.

2. First homebuyer activity spiked. 

First homebuyers were a sizable part of housing demand at the start of the pandemic. This cohort took advantage of more affordable housing options following the earlier downturn, along with record low mortgage rates and government incentives.

ABS data shows the number of new loans to first homebuyers increasing during the housing market downswing from 2017 to 2019 (figure 2.0). From June 2020, first home buyer activity surged amid the introduction of the HomeBuilder scheme, used alongside the First Home Loan Deposit Scheme, as well as other state-based grants and stamp duty concessions for first homebuyers. 

The result was a spike in first homebuyer activity, which peaked in January 2021. The spike mirrors first homebuyer participation in 2009-10, which marked a temporary boost to the First Homeowner Grant. Since the January 2021 peak, first home buyer activity has diminished, reflecting higher barriers to entry as housing values substantially outpace incomes.

As of January 2022, loans to first homebuyers numbered 10,964, above the decade average of 8,682. Proportionally, first homebuyer lending comprised 24% of owner occupier mortgage demand in January, which is in-line with the decade average.

This may have implications for rates of home ownership, which may see an increase on ABS 2016 census numbers. While the rise in home values has created a greater deposit hurdle for those looking to enter the market, various government schemes introduced throughout 2020 helped to incentivise first homebuyer participation. 

3. Rents rose 11.8% to record highs, while gross yields fell to record lows.

The CoreLogic Rent Value Index, which tracks changes in rental valuations over time, has also surged to new record highs. 

Figure 3.0 shows the change in the national rent index since the end of March 2020. While rents saw a mild decline of -0.8% between March and August 2020, there was a swift recovery in these values, followed by a surge through 2021.

There are multiple reasons rents have risen. Investor activity had been relatively subdued between 2017 and mid-2020, contributing to rental supply constraints. Rental supply may also have been eroded through the rise of rental services like Airbnb, which have enabled property owners to pivot to the short-term rental accommodation market. This latter trend may have been particularly prevalent in tourism destinations across Australia, some of which have flourished amid a rise in domestic tourism in the past two years. For investors who have recently purchased long-term rental accommodation, rents may have increased due to higher purchasing prices. 

Over the course of 2021, annual rent value growth was at its highest levels since 2008. Across Australia, median advertised rents since March 2020 have increased $30 per week to $470 per week. The headline numbers hide the diversity of rental conditions. Through the pandemic, there has been a clear shift in rental preferences towards lower density housing options, where the upwards pressure on rents has been more substantial. This trend has evolved over the past year, with rental affordability gradually deflecting more demand towards higher density rental options where the cost of renting is more affordable. 

However, gross rental yields have declined. This is because gross rental yields are a portion of the purchase price of a property, and purchase prices of properties have grown 24.6% since March 2020, outpacing the 11.8% rise in rents. Nationally, gross rental yields have fallen from 3.8% at March 2020 to a record low 3.21% as of February 2022. As housing growth has started to slow, this record-low gross rent yield figure appears to have begun stabilising. 

4. Housing debt levels hit record highs.

Rapid increases in housing and rent values in the past two years was largely the result of a sizable reduction in the official cash rate. With the RBA setting the official cash rate target at 0.1% since November 2020, lower debt costs enabled borrowers to access more credit. 

As of January, total outstanding housing credit sat at a record high of over $2 trillion, according to the RBA, while the ratio of housing debt to household income was at a record high 140.5% through Q3 2021 (figure 4.0). This is up from 139.2% in March 2020.

While total outstanding credit reached over $2 trillion in January, ABS data shows monthly new finance borrowed for the purchase of property continued to hit fresh record highs through January 2022, at $33.7 billion. 

High levels of housing debt, particularly where it has grown faster than incomes, creates a vulnerability in the Australian economy. However, it is important to frame debt levels in the context of high asset values, and relatively low interest costs. RBA data shows housing interest payments to income have fallen to their lowest levels since 1999, and household debt has trended lower as a portion of housing values. 

5. The premium of house prices compared to units hit record highs. 

Both the composition of the buyer pool and the impacts of COVID may have contributed to a record gap between house and unit values. Investors, who may have a preference for units, have been a relatively small part of demand through the upswing. Additionally, detached houses may have been in higher demand as Australians spent more time at home through the pandemic. Government policies such as the HomeBuilder grant may have also contributed to increased detached housing demand, due to tight construction timelines to qualify. 

The result is a record high gap between house and unit values. Figure 5.0 shows the median house value across Australia was at a record high 29.8% above the median Australian unit value, with a dollar value premium of around $182,000. This is up from just 8.5% in March 2020, or a dollar value premium of around $44,000 for houses. 

Figure 6.0 shows the dollar-value premium of median house values over median unit values in each of the capital cities, with most cities seeing a substantial increase in this value since March 2020.

6. The rise of the regions.

Migration trends over 2020 and 2021 revealed an uptick in the volume of people leaving cities for regions outside of lockdown periods, and a decline in people leaving regions for cities. 

The result has been higher than normal housing demand against unusually low levels of listings across regional Australia, in both the sales and rental market. Value gains across regional Australian dwelling values has been almost 40% since March 2020, while capital city home values have increased around 21% (figure 7.0).

In lifestyle regions, which have become intensely popular in the past two years, new million-dollar markets have been created across areas such as the Sunshine Coast, the Illawarra and the Gold Coast, where median house values now sit above the million dollar mark. 

Where to from here? 

The current housing market upswing has delivered extraordinary value gains, providing a significant wealth boost for home owners, but larger hurdles to enter the market for non-home owners. But since April of 2021, monthly gains in national home values have softened. Arguably, there are more headwinds than tailwinds now stacked against continued growth in the property market, with the potential for sooner-than expected cash rate increases, affordability constraints, and weakening consumer sentiment slowing demand. While some structural shifts through the pandemic, such as remote work, may sustain demand in regional Australia long term, it is likely that housing values will start to decline on a fairly broad basis later this year. 

18

Nnyck777
Added 4 years ago

Hmmm - fun post @Hackenbacker. I wonder where this will all end? I would suggest a fun experiment - lets promote further negative gearing in the next election, watch the interest rates rise, see continued reduction in immigration and add further AirBNB houses in to the mix and see what sticks.

I find it interesting to note that many cities around the world are limiting AirBNB numbers at local government level. Apparently Santa Barbara acknowledges it has such a limited land supply and vacancy levels that it has dramatically limited the number of allowances for AirBnB properties so that locals can actually afford somewhere to live.

Throw in a few more weather disasters/ floods/ fires and I think that Australian housing policy may hit critical mass. Can you imagine either the Labour or Liberal government trying to touch or alter negative gearing in this country it would be policy suicide. Interesting times ahead.

10
Solvetheriddle
Added 4 years ago

Hi Guys

Another interesting chart imo. alot happening atm. fci is financial conditions. which should tighten as the Fed raises rates and plans to reduce its BS

IMO Mo is a default if you play that game, no real info. the rest shows how styles and sectors historically have behaved in a tightening environment. i read this as full tightening cycle

to me most of this is all as expected but there may be some on SM that are unfamiliar with this stuff,

sourced from the market ear and GS


1ce90b079dec4abf1a2771840d7ce9d9967142.png

8
Solvetheriddle
Added 4 years ago

Hi All

I thought the below was of interest. sourced from the Daily Shot

My take is the following, on a historic measure much of the damage is already done, even with a recession.

There is a growing chance of a meaningful economic slowdown coming which to me means if you are to stay in the market have a defensive skew, I come to a slowdown through looking at HY spreads and the yield curve slope, let alone Putin induced etc consumer headwinds that may appear-energy food

IMO commodities strength will sow the seeds of their own ultimate fall


e36a515f53c376eea3643859ec155a3eafe90a.png

15

Strawman
Added 4 years ago

Interesting chart @Solvetheriddle

I think yours is a good take -- on an average basis, assuming we see a recession, most of the damage has already been done. There are always edge cases of course, so this guarantees nothing, but i definitely think it's a useful perspective.

One thing I'm mindful of is that things will likely be worse at the small cap end of the market. In fact, in good times and bad, the moves are exaggerated in this space. The Strawman Index is a sign of that, I think. While we thumped the market during the good times, we've been hit harder than the 'blue chips' during this latest downturn.

In the world of "high beta" small-cap stocks, I see this as a feature, not a bug, and it is what provides the opportunity for outsized returns across the cycle. But it does test you during times of volatility.

Personally, my concern is that while a lot of the companies that I own have seen good progress on the business front, a big part of the historic returns were generated through multiple expansion -- 15 years ago few people would consider a price to sales ratio of 20 as sensible, but (until recently) that became common place. It was never part of the thesis, but you're not going to knock it back! Trouble is, "trees don't grow to the sky", and market multiples have a way of reverting to the mean. Add to that the fact that the market is now a lot more wary of loss making operations, and with rising inflation/rates, those stocks whose cash flows are still a few years out are given less rope.

Hindsight would suggest that cashing out late last year was the best move, but i'll never lose any sleep over that. Having predicted 10 of the last 2 corrections (to paraphrase the old joke), I think i'm best served just staying invested and rolling with the punches.

What's more important is to ensure my current expectations are well grounded. And here, honestly, my view is that more than a few of my stocks aren't likely to get back to previous highs anytime soon. That being said, given the size of some of the falls, i think the value proposition at current prices looks a pretty reasonable -- even if I pull back on some of my previous growth and multiple assumptions. I could entirely imagine further falls in the months ahead, but I'm trying to keep my gaze focused on what these stocks look like in 3-5 years time.

2022 will probably be remembered as a painful year for investors, but hopefully one that also presented some great opportunities. I just hope i choose the right ones!

34

Rapstar
Added 4 years ago

In terms of macro indicators, VVIX/VIX ratio, High Beta/Low Beta ratio, Small Cap/Mega Cap ratio, Value/Growth ratio in US markets have all turned bearish VAMS. The 4 indicators are a leading indicator of a significant market downturn when all 4 turn bearish. This was triggered this week. I was hoping I had a few more months before it was triggered, but it seems the Ukraine conflict brought forward the trigger.

US Defensive assets are also now leading cyclical assets with respect to hedge fund asset allocation. Another GTFO indicator.

High Beta assets have copped a pounding since November (they are the first to feel tightening liquidity), but the broader ASX 200 is down less than 10% from all time highs. In the US, the Russell 3000 is down less than 20% from all time highs. The Russell 3000 can potentially fall to 50-60% from ATHs in a big correction.

The US Fed has not even started tightening, and with full employment and inflation about 7%, the Fed is not getting any signals to back off. I think It will tighten until we get a March 2020 event, as all the signals are saying they need to kill demand.

Be careful with commodity investments - some prices will remain elevated & some not - depending on demand in a pending recession. Keep close to the exits.

In High Beta assets ? I certainly am - be prepared to take further losses - we may be only halfway through the high-beta bear market. If you hold high beta and can't get out due to liquidity and want a hedge, you could short SPHB (US small cap high beta ETF). There is some currency risk, but if there is a global recession coming (and leading indicators are pointing to this), the USD will likely outperform AUD (as AUD is a 'risk on' currency). Not advice - just an idea I am using........

Apologies for being so bearish - it is the reason why I have been quiet over the past few months - I have little positive to say.

Best of luck out there all..............A rare buying & life changing event is getting closer. Just don't lose your shirt buying the dip right now.





26