Forum Topics (Not so) Small Cap Manager
Noddy74
Added 3 months ago

Can anyone guess who this so-called Small Cap Fundie is?

62dc8646a1e7674de8c960071b27fb3183694b.png

Here's a hint. Holdings include:

TechOne $7.5 billion MC

Pinnacle $3.5 billion MC

Lovissa $3.4 billion MC

Hub24 $4.5 billion MC

It amazes me they get away with it. They get to compare themselves to a benchmark that has underperformed for years. They're hardly friendless but these guys are the most egregious I've seen.

18

mikebrisy
Added 3 months ago

Montgomeries Small Company by any chance?

It does seem odd on first view, but I just had a look at the ASX Small Ordinaries, which is the fund’s benchmark, and $HUB at $4.5bn is the largest constituent.

$TNE has “graduated” but was probably in the benchmark when the fund was established.

77da35eb17010f1ea8741cc731728cae51d8cd.jpeg

On closer inspection, the benchmarks definition is that it aims “to include companies in the ASX-300 that are not in the ASX-100.”

I normally think of anything >$2bn as mid-cap. But hey, what do I know? So maybe it is small if your reference is $BHP, $CBA and $CSL.

13

Noddy74
Added 3 months ago

You're a more charitable soul than me @mikebrisy

I was surprised at some of the names in the Small Ordinaries but the vast majority are under $2 billion. Although there's no official definition, I borrowed a couple of members of your analytic team (they work weekends!) to give a guide and they suggested the accepted consensus is $100 million to $2 billion - $300 million to $2 billion in the U.S.

More to the point I think if you're going to call yourself a Small Cap Manager it would reasonable to think you're going to give a little more love to the tiddlers than old four-eyes does.

14

mikebrisy
Added 3 months ago

Hah! My team can work very hard and quite effectively when properly directed and supervised, and they are quite well trained! :-)


11

Solvetheriddle
Added 3 months ago

Any PF’s involved they should hand them back

4

Mujo
Added 3 months ago

My understanding is that the 'mid cap' term is really only starting to appear in Australia over the last few years.

Previously my understanding of with the Ausie fundie industry convention was:

  • Large cap was ASX 100.
  • Small cap was ex-ASX100 to <$300M market cap.
  • Micro Cap <300M>


Think Mid cap is now what ex-50 though think some would even argue ex-20.

I think if a small cap fundie isn't outperforming the small ords by 4%pa they're underperforming - just a benchmark with mostly trash.

6