Forum Topics QAN QAN The Chairman's Lounge

Pinned straw:

Added 11 months ago

Agree @Mujo just finished reading ‘The Chairman’s Lounge” by ex AFR journalist Joe Aston.   I guess we all knew or came to know just what a piece of work is Alan Joyce. 

Only matched by incompetence and obsequiousness of the then Qantas chair Richard Goyder.  Sadly for some investors Goyder remans the chair of Woodside.    

The book blasts apart any assumption that those in high places will act decently - or are even competent.  

A great read, however with what Aston reveals in the gossipy parts I don’t think the book would be a favourite on the Prime Minister’s Christmas reading list.


jcmleng
Added 11 months ago

A different perspective from me.

I am no fan of Joyce. Having seen many other airlines go bust because of bloated costs, I get why he needed to do what he did, but HOW he went about to do what he did is another matter entirely - history has rightfully judged him harshly and each of us wil have our own views on it.

I was eagerly anticipating the book - drove to various stores to hunt it down the day it was published. But about 2-3 chapters in, it was clear that this was an all-out personal attack on Joyce, Groyder etc, and there was deliberately intended collateral damage to many along the way. A recap of the "see-I-was-so-smart-to-point-it-all-out" points made during the turmoil with the complete benefit of being able to piece/re-piece the narrative with full 20/20 hindsight.

It really felt like Joe completely played the persons, not the ball. I have always struggled with smart-arsey journalists who think they have figured it all out from the sidelines - Joe was undoubtedly top dog, but this book took it to a new level.

This completely crossed the line for me, from what started as really good investigative journalism, to outright, relentless personal vendetta. Wish I hadn't read it over the festive season ...

16

Mujo
Added 11 months ago

Think the personal attacks were to be expected - it is what AFR rear window was under him. He was particularly bad in the first few chapters and about 3/4 through.

Him also siding with people like Sally McManus etc also not a great look - still if you can look through that I think it gives some good insights into the innerworkings of government and the major airlines.

13