Pinned straw:
@PortfolioPlus, you could be describing me in your post. I think i have had all of those thoughts. At least if we are both idiots then we are not lonely idiots!
Like you I was confused by the market response to what I considered to be a good set of results in what was an already an undervalued company. You know your in an unloved company when you increase EPS by 10% and your share price declines by 10%.
I listened to the earnings call and I thought it was all pretty positive. They have their strategic roadmap and are executing against it quite well. The leadership team appear to work well together and are all on the same page. I see a lot of similarities with Minres in that the story that is getting all the focus is the gearing and risks associated, without appreciating that this risk enables the business transformation. Securing the vendor finance last year as a backstop for AQZ I think really reduced the potential of a uncontrolled bad outcome.
Another aspect which I am only starting to appreciate is how investors become irrational about dividends, I think AQZ is being punished for suspending the dividend a few years ago, when they started the plane purchases. The emotion in the question around this on the call, and similiar queries in previous meetings makes me think some investors feel betrayed when these get paused and are now moving on to greener dividends. The combo of a declining SP and no dividends is probably hard to take when the broader market is increasing. I think it is totally the right call by AQZ to focus on the debt repayments and expansion plans and suspend the dividend in the short term.
I raise the dividend as it seems an important psyche milestone, I notice that stealth really popped when it started paying its dividend and it looked like it suddenly became invest able for a wider segment of the community. Likewise Evolution maintained (but significantly reduced) their dividend a few years ago during a similiar high debt/reduced cashflow period but it has now let them make statements like this is the 20th continuous dividend paid.
I also think the industrial action and increase in staff costs could also play a part in the sell down as this did come as a surprise but makes sense given the comments Scott made in last years strawman interview. I am reasonably confident that these costs will get predominantly past on, and they indicated as such on the call, but if they cant then the 15-20mil hit to the bottom line would be hard.
To me the important metrics are all going in the right direction and at a current PE of 6.5 its not hard to see the upside. The money is made in the waiting right.