Pinned straw:
A merger makes sense, and as a holder of both in RL, I'm happy with the proposal on the face of it.
A big pop in both share prices today (and probably another small one post merger when the indices rebalance) means the market is happy in the short term, but I think it'll be a good move in the long run as well.
Yippe it's good when your thesis works out! the first clue to this was the SOL merger with Milton a couple of years ago. That showed SOL was in the mindset of significant corporate change. I thought they were waiting for Lindsay Partridge to retire to buy out BKW, so I started getting disheartened as time went by after he retired. Having said that, I think BKW as a standalone is worth mid-$30s due to the property portfolio, but also the cross-shareholdings make it complicated. so probably fair enough on first blush.
as an aside, i wonder what Mat Williams at Airlie thinks about this, as you recall he took them to court to force a demerger, rumour is he lost his job over it when head of PPT equities, funny how the wheel turns.
Good details of this on the Soul Patts website. https://yourir.info/resources/4b1a443a62bafee4/announcements/sol.asx/2A1599425/SOL_Investor_Presentation_Merger_of_Soul_Patts_and_Brickworks.pdf
I didn’t see this coming either, but I’m also not that surprised… if that makes any sense.
With the cross-ownership between the two companies plus the shared Chair (Rob Millner) and the Millner family’s controlling interest in both companies, it was probably only a matter of time. Is it a good thing? My gut says yes. I’ve got full confidence in Uncle Rob and Todd Barlow, and if the Milton merger (aka takeover) is anything to go by, these guys know how to get maximum value from these mergers - not their first time.
Still, it does feel like the end of an era.
DISC: Soul Patts makes up around 20% of my IRL portfolio, so I’m definitely biased.