Forum Topics Glassdoor Reviews
mikebrisy
2 years ago

I use Glassdoor reviews but, as with all online reviews, I apply some judgement. For example, I tend to discount reviews that have the flavour of being by a disgruntled employee trying to lash out. Equally, I try to detect very well written glowing reviews that sound like they may have been written by an HR or PR team. Of course, you never can tell, but in the reviews that feel like they might be genuine, I then look for common themes across multiple reviews over time around organisation politics/culture, incentives, leadership, people development, morale, workload sustainability, focus on customer value etc. (These are the same skills I have developed over the years when looking at hotel and restauramnt reviews!)

If there are enough reviews, then there can be a subset that give some insights into the organisation culture, values, and effectiveness. Because of this, I take the Glassdoor metrics with a grain of salt, as they are based on all reviews. So, for example, there can be a strong positive bias in a small company with few reviews using the platform for promotional purposes.

It is one of many soures of information out there, and I think it can be helpful.

16

edgescape
2 years ago

Thought I'd revisit this topic again this time looking at some of the negative reviews which provide some useful inside information.

Without naming specific ASX companies, here is one I found regarding a diagnostic company:

d00235f41b5966e9670c2c83325fc2f622b887.png

And here is another one for a small tech company. I don't know much about Ruby so I can't comment on the view below:

b97773cf15de85859baa7ec7f711d2dd865702.png

And a few more this time for a small medtech company

eb9950777bbcfdc206d008749cef0ab3afacc3.png

ae2020aad2bc236c8e6c1b823a2da6c97184f1.png

Some valuable insights in the issues faced by small companies balancing employee retention and welfare while growing their business. It is probably no wonder the bigger the company is, the easier it is to retain top talent and hit milestones.

Of course, it could be different if the company is working on some bespoke technology which no one has heard of before yet has the potential to change lives.

14
edgescape
2 years ago

I've been using glassdoor less and less. It's quite easy to put in a fake review and say the company is really good to work with. I suppose the upside is that it in a way is a bit of advertising for the company to attract the best talent!

Sometimes you have to read through the reviews quite carefully. There was one review on Beamtree where the employee mentioned they were sometimes falling behind on deploying trials to customers which I thought was insightful.

I still find the ASX reports / presentations are the best sources of information:

One example (sorry for spruiking DVP again - definitely not financial advice after the continual uptrend on no news in the past few weeks!)

61c4f79323439f431d78978e76ad5326abc793.png


9
Seasoning
2 years ago

Glass door is a useful information point, i always consider the type of business. I rarely expect a retailer to be rated well for example

12

Does anyone have any insight into Glassdoor reviews? Are they fairly reliable? Is it possible for a disgruntled ex-employee to create multiple accounts to leave more than one poor review?

I'm assuming yes to all of the above but would love some input from people who have used this site to assess a company before.

Thanks.

6

AlphaAngle
4 years ago

Just one piece of information that can help you do your due dilligence. Part of my process after reading the theranos story and how they were always madly trying to delete the glassdoor reviews to cover up thier fraud.

6

Noddy74
2 years ago

Had a bit of a giggle reviewing Glassdoor reviews for one of my holdings. Between mid-2021 and late-2022 they had just one review. Then in the past two months they've had four. All five star, all couldn't think of a single negative, all approve of the CEO. Someone in HR has too much time on their hands...

22

Timocracy
2 years ago

Other than Glassdoor which could definitely provide a skew towards a) disgruntled employees or b) employees that have an incentive to give a good review, one trick can be to check out the company profile on LinkedIn and see how long people tend to stick around. A couple of clicks beyond that and you can see if it’s a place people want to work or if the individuals are job-hoppers. Hard with “newer” companies though.

18

Strawman
2 years ago

Nice one Tom

6

Seasoning
2 years ago

Nice! I definitely think at the very least, having a good reputation for good people and culture is going to make it easier to hire and attract talent. Having that kind of quality in the company is going to help in the long run.

In my research, I'm looking for any specific insights worth further scrutiny whether they be a complaint or compliment around the company.

What generally are people complaining about? are there any themes? are there any things I can verify. For example, if people in a tech company are complaining about technical debt and a lack of investment in improving things - do I have access to their product where I can find signs of this? can I look at technical choices? can I look at their team structure on linkedin etc.



9