Pinned straw:
@Nnyck777 as far as I can tell, it looks like one of the two analysts covering $VHT updated overnight. It will be clearer early next week.
So the update has reduced FY24 eps, however I think the price target has increased slightly for a combination of factors:
In terms of my own modelling, I don't have a valuation of $VHT, as it is meaningless to do a DCF at this stage. I am more focused on understanding the slope of the cash flow line.
Relevant to that is how the margins are evolving (in addition to the 5-year FCF picture I posted yesterday).
Here is the %GM picture, which is showing some economies of scale - however, this might also be due to product mix, i.e., the acquired businesses appeared to have had stronger gross margins. In any event, it looks consistently strong around 92%,
However, the good news is that we are seeing good scaling on expenses.
It is the progression of expenses relative to revenue in FY24 that will be the biggest driver in the FY24 eps outcome.
My own forecast, using two different methods, are from -NZ$0.025 to -NZ$0.007, but when earnings are so close to breakeven, things like government grants, tax and interest are significant swing factors, so frankly at that level of resolution its anyone's guess.
It is hard to predict, because it is unclear what the exit runrate was, how much the expense line was hit by severance costs in-year, and how successful Terri will be in holding expenses flat in FY24.
Overall, my optimism is predicated on the following short term factors:
and that these trends continue for a few years.
My quick calculation has an eps in FY26 of 1.9cps. If the SP is $1.00, then the p/e would be 52. Discounting back at 10% thats a SP today of NZD$0.75 or $A0.72. To be honest, that's a bit steep if they are only growing revenue at 20% p.a.
However, if the tailwinds allow revenue growth to be 25% p.a. (and I know they are only guiding 10-15%, but I think they might be conservative), then I get FY26 eps of 4.8cps. That higher growth would justify an exit p/e of 40, give a SP of NZ$1.92. Discounting back to today gives a SP of NZ$1.44 or A$1.38.
That's my bull case. But that is why I am only holding a small parcel, To increase my holding they have to a) outperform on their current revenue growth guidance and b) manage expenses growth.
There is, in addition, a potential M&A take-out premium to consider. Probably a 50% chance at a 40-50% premium, but I have'nt factored that into my expected value.
For now, I will put my SM Valuation at ($0.72+$1.38)/2 = $1.05.