@PabloEskyBruh yeah I see what you mean about the bond villan vibe and the belief that 100% positive outcome is the only possible scenario for them. I am starting to come around to his viewpoint though. They definately have what looks like a clinically superior device, and this a pretty strong position to negotiate from.
I think having the 12 month data from the initial patients, who all have had no complications at each checkup point, and are still having a very good outcome. This reduces the risk of valve failure at least over the initial 1-2 yr period. It would be interesting to know what their internal belief is on lifespan of the material used in the anteris valve is and at what timepoint if at all a replacement valve would be needed.
The flow chamber demontrations of how the valve works and how backflow pressure is minimised and is much more comparable to a real heart than any of the existing valve products was an initial positive, but for this to then be backed up in the actual patients does provide a high degree of confidence that they have a market leading device that could easily supercede the use of the existing devices. As I doubt you could continue to use the outdated products from a medical ethics perspective give the lower quality of life outcome and need to be replaced in he future.
The successful valve in valve replacement trials is also a real positive and further demontrates the market need and use of their product. The description of how their valves are placed inside the degraded 2nd replaced valve through a leg catheter without being able to remove the debri left from the 1st two valves, and after the surgery they walk out with better health stats than when they had the previous valve installed.
My main crux with this is still the cash burn rate and how much of the value is linked to either a sale or a much longer term (>3yrs) commercial launch. I am expecting a cap raise announcement at some stage from them and a nice narratve helps this out. I have a feeling this might be one that I watch and almost buy and then regret not buying when they end up selling themselves to Edwards or Medtronic for 10x the current price.