Top member reports
Consensus community valuation
Contributing Members
Sort by:
Create your free Strawman account to view member valuations
#Broker/Analyst Views
Last edited 3 months ago

29-Jan-2021:  Taylor Collison: HRL Holdings Limited (HRL): Delivering Resilience Again

  • Analyst:  ROBIN MORGAN,, +618 8217 3900,

Our View

Resilience again shown as HRL’s predominantly NZ exposures bounce back from April’s COVID lockdown. We very modestly increase our FY21 forecasts despite top end EBITDA guidance achievement, conscious of the seasonal H2 vagaries within key parts of food testing. Our broader positive thesis on HRL however remains, as does our Outperform recommendation and new $0.18 price target (equal weighted PE & EV/EBITDA valuation methodology). We like:

  • More specialties to be carved out through disciplined innovation
  • A clear emphasis on stable markets, customer intimacy and share gains
  • Acquisition optionality again front of mind (and balance sheet supported)
  • Returning credibility after navigating meth contract loss & COVID disruption

Key Points Top end guidance met – A resilient 1H21 with sales held flat and 270bps of EBITDA margin expansion – partly JobKeeper attributable – despite cycling a prepandemic pcp. EBITDA guidance of $3.2-3.5m was met at the top end ($3.535m). Crucially, the core lab testing business – equating to c.80% of group earnings – delivered 13% top line growth and 28% EBITDA margins (vs. TC 26.8% forecast). The essential nature of much of HRL’s food testing and the tight management of overheads by a nimble and innovative executive team was clearly on show.

Seasonal variances to dictate where FY21 falls – HRL’s typical 1H:2H split is 40:60 to 45:55, suggesting an FY21 EBITDA closing in around $8m. Some conservatism is however needed in using this broad-brush approach, noting:

  • JobKeeper artificially boosted HRL’s H1 geotech business by $0.635m
  • The remnants of FY20’s bumper honey season spilt over into 1H21
  • The risk of wetter La Nina weather patterns may impact beehive yields

Given the above, and despite achieving top end H1 guidance, we only modestly upgrade our FY21 EBITDA forecast by 2.1% to $7.4m. At this early stage, the milk season is tracking normally, but the honey season start has been more muted.

Honey unlikely to repeat FY20’s stellar performance – FY20 was a bumper year for NZ honey. Beehive yields were high, with HRL only finishing last season’s testing this November. We understand recent volumes have been more akin to normal levels – significantly down on pcp – although more glyphosate and AFB testing (a type of bee disease) supports a solid outcome even in more normal FY21 settings. Not placing the usual weighting to 2H21 earnings seems sensible.

Strong cash flow and net cash – 1H21’s $0.6m net cash was achieved one result ahead of forecast. Operating cash flow of $3.2m (excl. $0.6m of wage subsidies) was driven by strong debtor collection and the extra earnings HRL was able to derive on a disciplined cost base. WC management was tight but did not change meaningfully. With $7m of available funding – cash and undrawn debt – and a credibility rebuild well underway, M&A optionality takes on more credence. Smaller bolt-ons are accessible but engaging with larger family-owned (Aus beachhead) targets remains more protracted.

Food Lab JV blue-sky – HRL’s Food Lab JV now expects commercial sales in 2H21 with profitability 2-3 years away. HRL has already proven itself capable of innovatively capturing market share in honey and raw milk markets. Should it become a recognised player in NZ’s broader $40m milk product market, achieving even low 30% margins, then over $2m of EBITDA could be delivered. That is equivalent to 30% of our FY21 base. Still in its infancy, but now more than just a blue-sky opportunity, the market may start placing a value on it over the mid-term.

  • Recommendation: Outperform
  • Market Capitalisation: $71.6M
  • Share price: $0.145 ($0.14 on 05-Feb-2021)
  • Price Target: $0.18
  • 52 week low: $0.07
  • 52 week high: $0.18

--- click on the link at the top for the full TC report on HRL ---     [I do not hold HRL shares.]

Read More
#Broker/Analyst Views
Added 9 months ago
Read More
#Broker/Analyst Views
Added 10 months ago

11-June-2020:  Morgans: HRL Holdings: Add: Up to the test

Morgans have an "Add" call on HRL and a 14 cps TP, up 2c from their previous 12 cps TP.  HRL closed at 10.5 cps on Friday afternoon.  

HRL released this Update on COVID-19 and FY20 Guidance announcement to the market on the same morning that Morgans penned this latest research note (last Thursday, 11-June-2020).

Read More
#Broker/Analyst Views
Added one year ago

26-March-2020:  Morgans: HRL Holdings: Momentum halted by COVID-19

Morgans still have a n "ADD" rating on HRL, but they note that there is now higher risk.  Their TP has reduced from 16c to 12c/share.  At 8.5c to 9c/share, that suggests there is 33%+ upside from here if they're right.

Read More