Top member reports
No meetings
Consensus community valuation
The consensus valuation is for members only and has been removed from this chart. Click for membership options.
Contributing Members
Content is delayed by one month. Upgrade your membership to unlock all content. Click for membership options.
#Bear Case
Added a month ago

Thought I'd have a look to see how much of NTA gets drained just for this pile of crap to run every year.

We'll call it $1.65 mil in expenses each year. We'll leave the interest on the notes out because we're going to use Net Assets to calculate the MER.

Based on Net assets of $28.8 mil this means that this vehicle is sucking up 5.7% of NTA annually just to keep running.

That's being generous too, because I think it's debatable whether the deferred tax assets should be included in the calculation.


24f5e27e43620a4585b3365c1f64f93ad0dc8c.png

184a8808c56bdf1bb5393af8f091978bd4fd24.png

Read More
#Management
stale
Added 3 years ago

Doing further DD on this one. I like the strategy and think the managers are decent stock pickers however the fees and capital structure of this LIC are rubbish.
The management fee is 1.75% p.a of GROSS assets, meaning they get to slug shareholders for the convertible notes they have taken on as well.

They also charge 20% of perfromance over their benchmark which is standard.

In their monthly reports I also noticed that they report performance pre fees which I am not a fan of (Wilson does this as well). Once you factor in fees the perfromance of the vehicle has been pretty unremarkable.

Add to this that there are a bunch of options and convertible notes which will dilute NTA when converted/excercised.

This one is ripe for some sort of corporate action. Perhaps Wilson will come sniffing?

Still think the notes are the best way to play here.

View Attachment

Read More