Top member reports
No meetings
Consensus community valuation
XXXXXX
Average Intrinsic Value
XXXXXX
Undervalued by
The consensus valuation is for members only and has been removed from this chart. Click for membership options.
Contributing Members
Content is delayed by one month. Upgrade your membership to unlock all content. Click for membership options.
Valuation of $7.30
Added 2 months ago

Apr 2024 - 7.30. See previous straw on financials. Using 35mtpa. NPV8.


Nov 2023 - 4.95 (nb this is using 16mtpa which is wrong)

See previous straw on financials

NPV11 works out to be 345m for the Minres milestone and royalty payments.

Read More
#Bull Case
Last edited 2 months ago

52 week high at $6.80 today (19 Apr). FOMO has finally arrived

0e1eb890dd160becead26fcc55df13d02747fc.png

MinRes making Onslow their flagship project with the progress video right at the beginning of the FY24 presentation.

Has been good for Red Hill, not so good for Develop. Unfortunately I hold less RHI than DVP so this has not been a perfect "hedge". Because I think Red Hill is "boring" even though "boring" can sometimes be "good".

8913f793557712e1aea0a7992460b13c6f02b7.png

And Joshua Pitt track record has been average till now (marketindex). I guess the saying "Every dog will have its day" applies here?

25d6bbaeca3f28cf2e42eafce344168c11d449.png

A few bits of info to take away for more valuation into the research as again I think I've undervalued this somewhat (see previous straw on Financials)

Stage 1 is 35 mtpa. How long to wait till Stage 2? How big will be Stage 2? 50mtpa? 75mtpa?

3604008d53902da77c27de5faf40096709a5df.png

Map of the JV. Have to verify if there is more than just Red Hill in this royalty. Obviously more upside if there is.

cdc67e9224b11221ae0dc71f5ca4722a737ecb.png


[held DVP and RHI]

Read More
#Financials
Added 3 months ago

This is just simple back of the envelope stuff

Assuming that MinRes will stick with 35mtpa, I get the total royalty value just around $495m using NPV8

1ed10e74b2c0f9e2862f6b683010a14558f775.png

My last calculation used 16mtpa because I divided the 500mt reserve by 30 years which works out to be 16mtpa. So I inadvertently underpriced RHI by mistake.

Also the above assuming that MinRes will want to get a head start on Onslow as much as they can even if the reserve is less than 30 years..

The above calculation does not include dividends, expenditure spending on exploration and other projects. I've also not included any potential ramp up (say 35 to 50 mtpa) which will add more upside.

[held]

Read More
#Bear Case
Added 4 months ago

Giving the Iron ore majors (and the Iron ore price) a run for their money

Popped 10% today from 5.25 to 5.75 possibly on the back of recent updates on the Onslow project from Minires.

Markets obviously factoring high prob of $1.20 dividend (see previous straw).

d2f89a7c38aeb623fef974ee54cf64bbabce16.png

I also added CZR here since the company is in discussions on joint development of infrastructure for the Pannawonica (RHI) and Robe Mesa Project (CZR) which will obviously benefit both parties.

CZR is top performer so far as they are currently in discussions to sell their interest in Robe Mesa Project for $102 million to Miracle Iron resources (subsidiary of Shenzhen Naao Jiangian Invest Co (SNIC))

Such a development would probably benefit RHI as well if this goes as planned although the market is still divided on the probability of this being successful and hence coming off recent highs

c9a905253f9f1707e0e8fe9c65b7afd5f66461.png

Very illiquid though so buyer beware (and why not added in Strawman as it is too difficult to trade)

[held RHI]

Read More
#Financials
Added 4 months ago

Interesting to see the dividend payments (marketindex)

4cb4b8b83820469706f01d9cc211f32ce81883.png

28 October 21 was around the time RHI received their first 200m payment from the Minres sale

There is currently a 200m payment from Minres due in June 2024 if all goes to plan.

Strong probability that there will be another large dividend payment from this, possibly $1.20 per share and will also put pressure on the share price.

Would be better if RHI saved the money for an acquisition that delivers better potential returns rather than spending money on exploration of their tenements which have been fairly average of late.

[held]

Read More
#Business Model/Strategy
Added 5 months ago

Some recent exploration results below. Not enough to declare a gold discovery yet.

bbba9ac4c2e6e830a64d91016e31b74adb2654.png

I though the news above would be a negative but due to the upcoming MinRes payments and royalties (see my previous financials straws), the share price has stubbornly held firm and dividends are still being paid (have received the most recent payment).

Would be good if RHI can use the cash to find another promising project instead.

[held]

Read More
#Risks
stale
Last edited 9 months ago

Despite the negative news on iron ore and lack of success on exploration, RHI is still going up. Hit 52 week high

Just checked the queue and nothing on sale

Still doing my sums on those payments but I think some smart guys has already beaten me to it :(

Maybe just pull the trigger and push it to $5?

Edit:Very keen buyers at 5+

Also announced gold drill results.

Read More