Straws are discrete research notes that relate to a particular aspect of the company. Grouped under #hashtags, they are ranked by votes.
A good Straw offers a clear and concise perspective on the company and its prospects.
Please visit the forums tab for general discussion.
Feb 24
Target PE = 10, EPS expectation = 8.2c.
Valuation post-capital return = 82c
August 23
Target PE = 10, EPS expectation = 10c, Capital return = 18.5c.
Valuation pre-capital return = $1.185
Valuation post-capital return = $1
Feb 23
Maintaining valuation at 96c. Strongly backed by NTA of 69.5c or 89 of a 78c share price.
Sep 22
Downgrading based on recent guidance (see FY22 reporting notes straw). P/E target of 10 and earnings of $9.2 million. Therefore, a market cap target of $92m or 96c a share.
General notes:
Positives:
Negatives:
Has the thesis been broken?
General notes:
Positives:
Negatives:
Has the thesis been broken?
Valuation:
Target PE = 10, EPS expectation = 10c, Capital return = 18.5c.
Valuation pre-capital return = $1.185
Valuation post-capital return = $1
What are you expecting and what do you need to see over the next reporting season or generally into the future?
Expectations:
Questions to be answered:
Shiriro announced EBITDA profit of $17.6m down from a previously guided $18.5M. While a miss, this is only a small difference and potentially explained by the kitchen appliances business exit.
The cash on hand as of 30th June was $32.8m which is up from $6.4m at half year end. Around $12m of cash was expected from Omega exit. Leaving a $14.4m in cash change from changes in receivables vs payables, inventory reduction (excluding Omega products) and operating cash flows. Will need to see the balance sheet to see where to attribute the increase to. Hopefully, inventory reduction and operating cash flows...
Given the EBITDA guidance I expect NPAT of $8-9m. Market liked the announcement with shares up around 20% since its release.
The board released an announcement on Monday strongly implying at a return of surplus cash to shareholders. The wording of the announcement seems to imply this will be through a dividend rather than capital return. Given the $12 million of cash that the Omega sale was to produce through collection of debtors and inventory, I would expect a dividend/cash return of around $10 million above the normal dividend payout.
One of the reasons I bought Shriro was for the history of prudent capital allocation. Shriro has kept ROE above 15% on average over that last 3+ years. Shares are up 7% on the news today. Still on watch due to the potential performance downgrade due to the macro-economic environment.
General notes:
Positives:
Negatives:
Has the thesis been broken?
Valuation:
Unchanged at 96c.
What are you expecting and what do you need to see over the next reporting season or generally into the future?
An expected result, however, the outlook is weak. Need to closely monitor progress. Yield and NTA backing providing some confidence on any further downside risk.
Shriro announced on Monday that Kim Slater had resigned effective immediately. As described in my previous straw, Mr Slater was looking to stay on until a new director to replace him was found. John Murphy was appointed as a director effective immediately, Mr Murphy was nominated by Portfolio Services (part of Ariadne Australia (ASX:ARA)). As a result of these developments the extraordinary general meeting requested by Portfolio Services is no longer required, the outcomes from the meeting they were seeking have come to fruition.
The four person board is now made up of:
Moving forward, I would like to say that this is the end of the board issues. Overall, as stated previously I have no issue with this board composition as I can see the incentive for the primary shareholders to create value for all shareholders and the potential that Portfolio Services is using the board position as an activist for change within (just my person guesses here).
I wonder if Mr Slater could see the writing on the wall... If anyone could answer a question for me? Are directors able to see the votes/proxies as they are made prior to AGM/EGMs?
Shiro released a market update with the following guidance:
The revenue figure was in line with previous two years results while the EBITDA figure is down from the 12 months to Dec 21 figure of $26.8M and 12 months to Dec 20 figure of $32.3M. Management's reason for the decline in EBITDA was the increase in freight and fuel cost and additional expenses of a new ERP system and enhancing cyber security.
The board shenanigans should be resolved at an extraordinary general meeting (11 June). The major shareholders are looking to remove Kim Slater, he has already said he will retire but is not looking to be pushed before a new director is found. There is nothing positive about the recent board issues (two previous departures before this) besides the fact the large shareholders are taking over control, personally I have no issue with that. The appointment of John Murphy from Portfolio services (5% holding in SHM) is interesting from the outside it looks like they may be running an activist strategy with their SHM holding.
Will be downgrading valuation based on mid-range EBITDA figure. DA is normally around $6m, I is negligible and normal tax rate of 30%. This gives an NPAT estimate of approximately $12M. Maintaining a PE target of 10. This gives a target MC of $120M or $1.25 per share.
Shares are on watch for any further board issues or cost increases. Still holding due to the great yield expected that provides a very decent return on its own (10+% grossed up).
Overall Comment:
Overall, result was as expected or slightly better given the hit from east coast lockdowns. Current dividend yield is very high and NTA backing up the share price gives little downside potential to holders. The gross dividend yield by itself is giving me my expected pre-tax return of 15%+ at current prices. Thesis is based on Shriro management being good capital allocators, this continues to be the case with high ROE and high dividend yield. Loss of Bianco over the next year will hopefully be offset by the opportunities from the international BBQ market through the "Everdure by Heston Blumenthal" brand.
General Notes
Positives
Negatives
Has the thesis been broken?
Valuation
What are you expecting and what do you need to see over the next reporting season or generally into the future?
General Notes
Positives
Negatives
Has the thesis been broken?
Valuation
What am I expecting and what do I need to see over the next reporting season or generally into the future?
The loss of the Blanco distributorship isn't good news (10% of revenue), but not disastrous either. Agreement still has another 9 months to run...that's plenty long enough to find suitable replacements and train staff to offer the better alternatives from SHM's point of view. I mean if they cannot steer a customer to another brand they shouldn't be selling.
I don't believe the Blanco range is so sticky that someone will say 'Blanco or bugger off'
Let's not overlook the BBQ advantage. I bought more at 90c today because this still has great earnings potential. FY21 eps of around 23c (leaving aside the 6 months results because they are changing from CY to FY). Looking forward, yes we will see less apartments being built but more homes...still a need for the SHM range of products. It's not difficult to get a conservative IV at $1.24 so for 90c SP that's a reasonable margin of safety. Plus. look at the attractiveness of the grossed up dividend.
What does Shriro do:
Shriro is a kitchen appliance and consumer products marketing and distribution business. Brands include: Omega, Robinhood, Everdue, Casio, Blanco, Pioneer and Neil Perry Kitchen appliances. The types of products include: appliances, music equipment, BBQ, rangehoods, sinks, taps, calculators, heaters, watches and POS equipment. Most of their revenues come from Australia, with a small business in NZ. They are currently expanding globally in some product lines.
Main Thesis:
General Notes:
Positives:
Negatives:
What to watch for/risks:
Catalyst for purchase:
When to sell:
Disclosure: Based on research I am strongly considering taking a small position in SHM.
Thanks Noddy74 for your straws on SHM which got me interested in researhcing SHM.
Shriro gave a trading update at their AGM today, which for some reason they don't think is price sensitive but is. The headline number is +38.3% revenue growth vs pcp (Jan-Apr). It's a big beat but a little misleading given how sales fared in Mar-Apr 2020. The +11% revenue growth vs pcp (Jan-Feb) they revealed earlier in the year is a more sustainable comparison and is still an impressive number for a business of their type and maturity.
They also gave a forecast on international sales growth for Jan to Jun, which was revenue growth of 128% vs 2020 and 271% vs 2019 (they are changing fin year end in 2021 so Jan-Jun will be the full fin year). It's impressive - albeit off a low a low base - and gratifying given international markets is one of the levers they will be pulling on once housing construction slows in Australia (probably FY23). Being so confident to forecast international sector growth and not domestic (by far their biggest sector) seems a little selective and opportunistic, but they're not Robinson Crusoe in that regard.
Speaking of transparency they gave updates (commentary) on each of their product segments but as usual gave no indication of relative size of those segments, nor any metrics at all. This isn't new for them but is still a frustration. They don't own all the brands they sell and it should be possible to risk profile those they don't differently to those they do, but unfortunately they don't allow you to do this.
One other point to note was the Chair highlighting $17.6m cash and zero debt and stating "To further facilitate growth and as previously advised, the Board and Management will explore inorganic growth opportunities where they complement the strategic direction of the Company and can be value accretive. However, in the absence of that occurring, the Board and Management will reconsider the Balance Sheet position later in the year". I hope they find the acquisitions because that's the second big lever at their disposal once housing construction inevitably softens but if they don't acquire I read this as saying they'll provide a special dividend or share buyback.
[Significantly held]
***
Shriro Holdings Limited (Shriro) (ASX:SHM) has become aware today that Shriro Pacific, a substantial shareholder in Shriro, has sold 4,088,763 shares in Shriro.
Following the sale, Shriro understands that Shriro Pacific has a 19.89% shareholding in Shriro. A substantial holder notice will be lodged with ASX and Shriro within two business days.
***
Volume traded today represents more than 5% of the total shares on issue. Shares are down 7% today. You would like to see a tidier exit but such is the risk when trading in illiquid microcaps. The new shareholding means Shriro Pacific can't automatially appoint a board member and means non-market disclosed information cannot be shared between Shriro (ASX:SHM) and Shriro Pacific.
[Held and accumulating]
Shriro released a year end (31 Dec) guidance today. The SP has popped as a result. A bit unsure why as it's only a little higher than they'd previously indicated. I still think there's plenty of SP upside in this one and it's worth hanging around for a healthy dividend in the new year.
***
TRADING UPDATE AND OUTLOOK Shriro Holdings Limited (“Shriro”) (ASX: SHM) provides guidance to the market on its full year forecast results. Previously Shriro has communicated its first half profit and growth in revenue for the third quarter driven by the demand for household related goods. This growth in revenue and profit has continued into the fourth quarter and Shriro informs the market that in FY20: ? Revenue is expected to be in the range of $180M to $185M ? EBITDA is expected to be in the range of $29M to $31M; and ? NPAT is expected to be in the range of $15M to $17M. The result has benefitted from government wage subsidies of $3.7M and the head office lease exit benefit of $2.3M. Covid?19 also resulted in management making decisions to reduce costs relating to marketing, staff hours, travel and the organisation delayed its move to a new head office premises until 2021. These factors resulted in further efficiencies of approximately $4M. These decisions assisted in offsetting the negative impact of the Covid?19 related lockdowns on revenue in the months of March and April 2020. Shriro is not providing any forecasts of earnings for FY21.
***
[I hold SHM shares]
Shriro is my highest conviction holding in my actual - not Strawman - portfolio. I bought into this after seeing an article on Livewire (https://www.livewiremarkets.com/wires/the-best-value-stock-to-own-is-a-growing-value-stock) and then started looking into it. This is purely a value play so if you are exclusively about growth let me sell you a Tesla share.
What I like:
- $20m cash (and $28m inventory) for a company that had sub-$60m market cap when I bought in
- has started growing revenue. This was curtailed somewhat by COVID but I don't see this as being structural and it was partly shielded as its diverse range includes some of the consumer discretionary items that got a boost from COVID.
- has gone through a cost out exercise in H1 already
- simple balance sheet with no debt, no intangibles, no funky financial instruments
- it converts profit to free cashflow and pays it out as dividends ( I have mixed feelings about the value of dividends but if they can't find a better use for the money I'm ok for the to give them to me and I will).
What am I cautious of:
- is COVID impacted
- the cost out is great but that's a one trick pony and you don't cut your way to sustained profit
- is dependent on maintaining licensing deals
- it's very tightly held
06-May-2020: CCZ Equities Research: Shriro Holdings Ltd (SHM): Difficult retail environment remains, weak forecast retained
CCZ have an unchanged "HOLD" recommendation on SHM; they have also maintained their 43 cps TP. Shriro closed at 44 cps today (13-May-2020), so no upside from here according to CCZ.
26-March-2020: CCZ Equities Research: Shriro Holdings Ltd (SHM): FY20 going to be tough, but this is a dependable long-term business
CCZ have an unchanged "HOLD" recommendation on SHM but they have lowered their TP from 69 to 43 cps. I looks like Shriro are going to close at 41 cps today, so not much upside from here according to CCZ.