Templeton Global Growth Fund (ASX:TGG) June 2019 Quarterly Report
This is an interesting LIC that I hold shares in (although it's another one that never made it onto my Strawman.Com scorecard).
They are definitely value investors despite having "Growth" in their name. They are NOT growth investors, other than believing (as the company's founders did) that you can GROW your investment capital by investing in quality companies when those shares are available at a material discount to their intrinsic value. Of course, the best approach is to have a value investing mindset and to target those companies with good growth outlooks. The traditional growth investor tends to have little time for intrinsic valuations (the stuff that value investing is based on) and buys companies who have share prices that are rising. The trend is their friend, ...until it isn't.
The past 10+ years have been very good for growth investors, and rather challenging for the traditional value investors like TGG. In fact TGG has underperformed their benchmark (the MSCI index) over all timeframes up to and beyond 10 years. So Why oh Why would you invest in such a poor performing LIC?
There are a couple of reasons.
1. The Wilson Asset Management Group (WAMG) owns 10.18% of TGG - which they hold in their WAM Active (WAA) & WAM Capital (WAM) LICs. Geoff Wilson has a track record of encouraging improved performance in underperforming LICs via a number of means, including the threat of WAMG taking over the management of the LIC themselves, which most recently occurred with CYA - Century Australia Investments - which has now been rolled into WAM Leaders fund (WLE). Geoff doesn't always get exactly what he wants - he lost control of HHV (the Hunter Hall Global Value Fund) to Pengana (HHV is now PIA - the Pengana International Equities Fund), but when Geoff becomes involved in another LIC (especially when he buys a substantial holding in that LIC), it is generally a good thing for the shareholders of that LIC - or at least for the ones who were in it before Geoff did get involved. A word of caution however, WAMG have been substantial holders of TGG for a number of years now, so things aren't happening quickly there. One school of thought is that Geoff is waiting for his own global fund - WAM Global (WGB) - to establish a positive track record of outperformance - and then he will get serious about TGG.
2. In the meantime, we have TGG trying to appease their own shareholders (including GW) by improved communication, and active share buybacks. Additionally, they are increasing their dividends, including recently re-establishing their interim dividend for the first time in many years (they had been paying just the one final dividend each year).
3. Value Investing will have its time in the sun again, and that may well be during the bear market that follows this bull market. Growth investing tends to work best in bull markets, and not so well when markets are falling, because the companies on the most rediculously high valuations (the ones the growth investors are riding) are often the ones that get smashed the hardest when things turn south again. Growth investing relies on positive sentiment continuing, while value investing tends to ignore sentiment and focus on fundamental underlying (or intrinsic) value, value which remains there in both the good and the bad times. Value investors do best in the depths of bear markets when everybody is selling indiscriminately (running for the hills), because they have the ability to dispassionately buy quality companies that have become way oversold in the knowledge that, "this too will pass", and when the panic has run its course, eventually those companies will once again be priced on their earnings, quality and outlook. In other words, TGG may be one of those rare companies that actually outperform in a bear market. And bear markets always follow bull markets.
4. TGG is trading at a substantial discount to its NTA (net tangible assets), so you can effectively buy shares in a parcel of quality global stocks, like Royal Dutch Shell, BP, Oracle, Siemens, Citigroup, Wells Fargo, Allergan, Singapore Telecommunications, Sanofi and Standard Chartered, at a discount to what those shares are trading at on the market. You can then win in two ways - either via the SP-to-NTA gap reducing, or via the NTA increasing (and dragging the SP up with it).
Further reading:
https://www.franklintempleton.com.au/investor/resources/investor-tools/templeton-maxims
https://www.franklinresources.com/ftresources/about-us/history
https://www.intelligentinvestor.com.au/templeton-global-growth-fund-tgg-1806521
https://www.fool.com.au/2018/08/08/top-fund-manager-thinks-this-share-is-a-value-opportunity/
https://www.investsmart.com.au/investment-news/the-next-amp-capital-china-growth-fund/138146
[That last one is two years old, so much has occurred since Mitch Sneddon wrote it, but it's still worth a read]
Disclosure: I hold TGG shares.