Straws are discrete research notes that relate to a particular aspect of the company. Grouped under #hashtags, they are ranked by votes.
A good Straw offers a clear and concise perspective on the company and its prospects.
Please visit the forums tab for general discussion.
Great interview as always Strawman.
COO Philip seemed to get a little vague when he was asked specific questions. For example:
i) In relation to the competitor company Icardio with the product Echocardio, whom received FDA approval in the same month as EchoIQ. When asked what this competitor approval meant for EchoIQ, he responded they were about “measurement”. How the two FDA approved software systems differed and why the EIQ product was superior was not well explained.
ii) When asked the question in relation to progress of the Hydrix (HYD) 3 year agreement signed in April 2023 with EIQ to sell the “Echosolve” software in Australia NZ and Singapore, he was again vague. Philip talked about a pilot being extended out with Hendrix and these things taking time to get moving. Well, the total operational revenue in FY 24 was only $44,500. This does not speak to a business or relationship that is firing. In addition, you would think the recent FDA approval might have stirred some interest in the Australian market Philip could expand on.
iii) Philip was asked about the announced (16/9/24) Icardio.ai collaboration with Abbott to develop artificial intelligence for Abbott’s imaging devices, the response was along the lines of: Well, this does not preclude Abbott from entering an agreement with EIQ. A fair enough statement as far as it goes, but not one that would encourage an investor to open their wallet.
Maybe Philip is not giving too much away because of the competition and the critical stage the company is at. Fair enough too, and maybe I am being way too harsh.
It would be great if there is a Strawman Cardio somewhere out there in the medical heartland (note the ingenious word pun), or someone knows one whom can give an objective opinion on EIQ’s software? Because F*&^%ed if I know what to think.
@Strawman , great interview with Philip Woolff from EIQ. He strikes me as a man with great vision and a reasonably clear pathway to get where he thinks EIQ can go. It will be very interesting to see how the new American leader can start to commercialise their product in the new year. One question I have only just thought of that would have been worth asking is how long he thinks FDA approval would take for the heart failure side of the business - perhaps you can send him that and see if he replies. Once cash starts to flow it does seem like a favourable acquisition for a bigger US group, especially at its small valuation.
Nessie
disc: held
@Strawman , maybe you could reach out for another EIQ meeting. Lots of recent interest with the FDA approval. Hype in the stock price too, probably too much. Would be good to ask about how their research in to heart failure is going given it is potentially a bigger market.
Cheers,
Nessy
EIQ significantly derisked with FDA approval of AS diagnosis. Reimbursement codes next step and announcement of CEO should build momentum.
Highlights:
510(k) clearance secured from FDA allows for EIQ’s AI-enabled solution, EchoSolv AS to be marketed and sold in the USA
EIQ is in advanced discussions with a range of US healthcare providers around the potential uptake of EchoSolv AS – pipeline is well established with multiple groups
Ongoing liaison with device manufacturers and pharmaceutical companies advancing to broaden commercialisation pipeline
Work alongside US consultancy to obtain reimbursement codes for use of EchoSolv AS under insurance to scale up following FDA clearance
Company is well funded to advance multiple, near-term commercialisation opportunities
Advanced discussion with potential US based CEO with extensive healthcare, commercialisation and reimbursement experience.
“Following clearance, the Company is now aggressively focused on commercialisation."
Hot copper email sent out sharing a next investors article about EIQ. ("The Company has been engaged by EIQ to share our commentary on the progress of our Investment in EIQ over time").
Headline is that FDA approval could be any day now. The article does give a detailed run down on the company and outlines the risks. Their view is that it will take at least 12 months to ramp up sales. It does note that they have an investment in the company and include their investment memo.
Highlights of their thesis
"The data shows that the AI algorithm works.
Imminent share price catalyst in potential aortic stenosis FDA approval.
Multi-billion dollar market target for “heart failure” diagnostics assistant.
Second catalyst for FDA approval on heart failure could be within 12 months.
Exclusive commercial access to the world's biggest heart data repository
Clear pathways to commercialisation in the USA - the biggest healthcare market in the world.
SaaS revenue model, potential to rapidly grow revenue and/or secure large licensing deals.
Cost savings, 3 seconds until results, removing bias"
Could provide some momentum to the SP.
Disc: held in SM and RL
Investor presentation webinar gives some possible revenue and answers some of the questions regarding progress.
Anticipated reimbursement for Aortic Stenosis is US$68 of which EIQ gets 25% at ~90+% margin. US $8.5M ARR @10% market share (conservative 5M number of Echocardiograms only Medicare, total could be closer to 35M). In contrast the same market share for Heart Failure is $264 @25% or $42M as the penalties for hospitals are much higher if the patient returns to hospital following missed diagnosis or insufficient treatment.
Reimbursement allows EIQ to clip the ticket rather than charging the medical centre.
$4M cash burn in last 12 months. Stated that HF approval not needed to be a successful company. AS treatment in UK only @10% so large market expansion potential for device/ drug treatment.
HF FDA approval expected in the next 12 months. Reimbursement should follow shortly after.
Licensing discussions ongoing with device manufacturers, pharmaceutical firms and hardware producers. Expected to peak post approval and reimbursement.
Accepted that initial push on missed diagnoses had not been well received and so now focusing more on improved workflow and practitioner assist. Although the algorithm is black box they are trying to show how the numerical data generated leads to the decision to provide greater transparency.
Claiming competitors AI solutions were about improving the image rather than aiding the decision but pretty vague.
Suggesting that once a partner top US hospital is using the product, liability concern issues will drive wider adoption.
Following the study results announcement EIQ went into a trading halt for a CR. Despite earlier statements about options providing sufficient funding I had taken a small $1K position in RL assuming that a raise was coming and hoping to take part. However $7.1M was raised only from institutional investors @15c. "Several new institutional investors introduced to the register."
$4.65M for commercialisation, $1M for product development, $0.45M for FDA and trial costs and $1M for working capital.
47.4M new shares issued a dilution of 9% @5.4% to 5day VWAP so at least not heavily discounted. SP currently @16.7 so in the money.
EIQ announces positive study results for Heat Failure AI solution. FDA decision for Aortic Stenosis due soon and now pursuing approval for heart failure.
Highlights:
• Echo IQ recently completed two clinical studies to evaluate the performance of its Heart Failure AI system in detecting new onset heart failure:
o EIQ’s AI-alone detects 86% of heart failure cases (vs 46% detection observed in current standard clinical practice)
o Combination of AI and clinical evaluation increases diagnosis accuracy to 97% in high-risk individuals
• Heart failure is the leading cause of re-hospitalisation in the US, accounts for 17%(1) of all US healthcare expenditure and is a US$60bn market annually.
• Results were presented by invitation at Late Breaking Science sessions at the European Society of Cardiology (ESC) Congress 2024, the world’s largest and most renowned cardiology congress.
• Positive results form the basis for FDA application for EIQ’s AI solution as a diagnostic aid for the detection of heart failure.
• Groundbreaking results highlight EIQ’s potential ability to positively impact heart failure health economics – Reimbursement strategy being progressed.
• Significant commercial interest established and expected to scale in light of significance of results.
“The current status quo is not acceptable, since many patients with heart failure do not receive a clear diagnosis, and similarly other individuals at risk of heart failure may not be identified. The results of these studies demonstrate our ability to positively change the diagnostic landscape and to improve on current practices, with the goal of enhancing our patients lives.”
Proposed regulatory pathway and commercial opportunities: Following the presentation of these results at ESC Congress 2024, the Company remains well placed to advance its regulatory strategy with an application for US FDA clearance for its heart failure solution. Work is now underway toward a pre-submission meeting with the regulator, which will provide additional insight into its clearance pathway. Concurrently, Echo IQ has been engaging with a number of leading global pharmaceutical companies and device manufacturers, with both on-market and planned therapies for heart failure and associated conditions. These results are expected to advance these discussions ahead of potential commercial uplift with counterparties.
So the new CEO from end of Jan 2024 is now the former CEO...... Never like those sorts of announcements. I wonder if it was anything to do with him buying 500k shares on market just recently.
Nessy
disc - held
Some developments here. First cash flows coming in from sales - extremely small, but a starting point. With R&D refund they only have 2 quarters before they will probably need to do a capital raise. There is a new product aiming at determining heart failure earlier and more readily. FDA approval papers to be submitted very soon (hopefully). My main interest lies in how big the potential market is and the reimbursement possible in the US. This is an educated "bet" on where this may go and I will follow the hopefully increasing cash flows with interest.
EIQ quarterly cash flow Q2 2024.pdf
Nessy
disc: held in SM and RL
No revenue for this quarter and a cash burn of $1.7M. Next quarter has $500K options already exercised (remainder CY24, 145M outstanding ranging from 4c to 30c) and $650K R+D rebate. Should see some small revenue start next quarter but with $3.3M cash a raise is looking probable. Significant revenue likely following FDA approval early CY24. IP protection noted in quarterly report as a priority.
Pathway to FDA on-track, with reader study underway and final clearance anticipated Q4CY2023 /Q1CY2024
Echo IQ and EchoSolv(TM) will also be featured by Hydrix Medical at the Cardiac Society of Australia and New Zealand Conferenced in Auckland, New Zealand in August 2023. Echo IQ's Chief Medical Advisor will also be speaking at this important regional conference.
Increased operating expenses, reflecting an emphasis on sales and marketing activities, are starting to yield positive commercial impact, as reflected by the new partnerships and contracts announced . The Echo IQ Board of Directors was enhanced with the appointment of Simon Tolhurst, an experienced lawyer with expertise in competition law and mergers and acquisitions.
Commissioned broker report with a valuation of $0.59 gives a good detailed overview of the company and investment thesis.
Based on our modelling of revenues and expenses, we see EIQ achieving breakeven at the EBITDA line in FY25.
Financing EIQ’s first product EchoSolv™ was launched in December 2022. Growing the business in the near term is dependent on cash from revenue which is currently generated solely by EchoSolv™. As such, and until the product is generating sufficient income, the company will be reliant on access to external funding.
Intellectual property EIQ is using a broad single patent approach across all conditions related to structural heart disease to protect its intellectual property. Its Australian provisional patent application (2022901868) is called ‘Systems and Methods for AI-assisted Echocardiography’. Intellectual property risk, notwithstanding the granting of the patent, could be offset by gaining a first-mover advantage, which – given the multifaceted commercialisation activity to date and lack of direct competition in imaging – seems within reach.
Further good results from second clinical trial with some comments in the announcement that suggests a marketing approach. Incorrect/inaccurate diagnosis leading to malpractice suits and an increase in recipients for device manufacturers. Trial was funded by one such company. Now to get the adoption and revenue going.
Echo IQ’s EchoSolv AI technology identified 72% more patients with severe aortic stenosis than human diagnosis alone
• Trial revealed that women were 66% less likely to have been accurately diagnosed than men using human-only assessment: EchoSolvTM resolves this discrimination
• Study was funded by Edwards Lifesciences (NYSE:EW)(Edwards Lifesciences Corp. engages in patient-focused medical innovations for heart disease and critical care monitoring. Its products are categorized into four main areas: Transcatheter Aortic Valve Replacement, Transcatheter Mitral and Tricuspid Therapies, Surgical Structural Heart, and Critical Care)
• Clinical trials now completed at St. Vincent’s Hospitals and Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center (USA) with more than 40,000 echocardiograms reviewed
• Trial results support rapid commercial deployment of EchoSolvTM in multiple sites and markets
In the United States, diagnostic errors affect an estimated 12 million adults each year. Furthermore, we know that 1 in 3 medical malpractice cases resulting in death or permanent disability are due to inaccurate or delayed diagnosis. EchoSolvTM has clearly demonstrated how valuable it can be in clinical practice and we are pleased to see a number of facilities in Australia and the US evaluating our technology.
Device manufacturers, such as replacement valve manufacturers, could potentially see an increase in suitable recipients for their proven therapies.
We look forward to sharing more news in the weeks ahead as Echo IQ starts to capitalise on these exciting results.”
Ultromics are in the same field received $33M in series B funding in 2021. Spun out of the University of Oxford and built-in partnership with the U.K.'s National Health Service (NHS). They already have partnerships with Mayo Clinic, Janssen, Microsoft Azure and the American society of echocardiography. FDA and CE Mark. Need to read more of the research to see where Echo IQ is going to have enough advantage to catch up in US / Euro market.
Ultromics receives FDA Clearance for its Breakthrough Device EchoGo® Heart Failure: An AI-based platform that enables precision detection of heart failure with preserved ejection fraction.