Top member reports
No meetings
Consensus community valuation
The consensus valuation is for members only and has been removed from this chart. Click for membership options.
Contributing Members
Content is delayed by one month. Upgrade your membership to unlock all content. Click for membership options.
#Bear Case
stale
Added one year ago

Nufarm hits 52 week low without much effort.

My guess would be due to the headlines about El-Nino being more likely with less rainfall.

I still see Orbis (Allan Gray) and L1 Capital still large holders. Perhaps they still hold faith that Nufarm can still deliver the large revenue target for FY26

Also State Street has increased holding perhaps to hand out stock for short sellers

Given the situation, not going to average down here.

[held]

Read More
#Norway approval upside risk
stale
Last edited one year ago

Firstly Norway is the biggest salmon aquaculture producer in the world

d2c37da6c406dba6e8682f4445ed1b1a1ae3c7.png

Getting the approval from Norway is significant for Aquaterra as it means big dollars to Nufarm. Unfortunately Nufarm has not communicated clearly on the revenue numbers. So the only way to look at is the most recent investor slides to get a good idea of the market opportunity.

8da5f7c535ebffa0967f5829ed55cf3020cb00.png

f54e20bac66ff49730df3c84632224def3f370.png

Let us assume that most of the Aquaterra sales are coming from Chile and a minority from North America.

From the 1st chart on Salmon production, there is obviously a large opportunity to capture some meaningful revenue when comparing Chile and North America (USA and Canada) with Norway.

With the drive to replace smaller fish feed (ie: sardines etc.) with something more sustainable and easier to produce, Nufarm could be well placed in generating lots of revenue, particularly in Norway.

Yes it is a recession and Yes people can forgo nutrition for days. But Aquaterra is a new market opportunity that could displace normal sources of fish feed for aquaculture.

And also rains appear to have returned to the American wheatbelt. Maybe Nufarm can start runninig down their inventory in USA

9472fc92c68544066d985e26d38afc97061dc7.png

The selling is well overdone. Aquaterra could potentially the peaks and troughs of other areas and give Nufarm some much needed consistency in earnings.

Topped up on the morning dip before the late buying in the afternoon.

[held]

25dedd3548000578b6d044bf5417d975971d5f.png

Read More
#ASX Announcements
stale
Added one year ago

Probably not the update I was looking for on North America but will accept it nonetheless. I have a feeling everyone was looking for an update on the impact of drought in North America like myself..

Norway approves Aquaterra Omega-3 oil for use in aquafeed

27e3a04de87cd7de70daa4ea882edb17f17388.png

0f05e844f762b2f840b64494bbcd4d4606e780.png

[held]

Read More
#Risks
stale
Last edited one year ago

Nufarm has underperformed of late so I went back to the call transcript:

4be676776bad17beeb2ecf395a000b7a8163f3.png

However I think the market begs to differ. Was reading that North America crop regions is still experiencing drought conditions which is bad for corn and soy and would make it hard to clear out inventory.

U.S. Midwest Drought Expands

e275393a41d76a1d2c1bf889e1f1d6df6a4c7c.png

5634e9fcd396539ce2322c0a55c159d5dc604a.png

No update from Nufarm on the above and seems every other broker is silent - but personally I think the brokers know and have already formed their top down thesis for Nufarm without telling anyone judging by the price action.

Not tempted to average down. More of a hold at this point given the above situation which is hard to control and is tax loss selling but also not good that Nufarm has not disclosed anything about the drought. But if they say tomorrow that we have a problem in America then that is a big tick the management is aware. Either way this could mean a delay to Nufarm's long term revenue plan and I still remember the livewire articles touting the massive revenue growth story.

On the other hand, Hostplus Super just became substantial holder and have been big buyers along with Allan Gray.

[held]

Read More
#Financials
stale
Added 2 years ago

Finally have a good news cyclical agricultural story.

Nufarm released results and comfortably beat expectations sending the share price rallying 14%.

365a8ed92e2415845d4c819694e714291ac047.png

EPS came above consensus and dividend up from 4 to 5 cps.

a867522871641942ad21df9a85c44197a64cdf.png

Sales down but still above analyst consensus. Nufarm is reiterating their aim of growing revenue to $4.6B pa by FY26

e952b790b15f16df97c368f0fb1b039b920143.png

Working capital and inventory for America would be the only negative but they expect that will be drawn down next period. Also the debt growth is another negative.

The ones who sold yesterday would be having a pretty bad day today.

f5493da2cc92d0bb474e117f362cd435f32c54.png

To be fair to those that sold yesterday, today's trading doesn't make trend.

And probably no one expected anything special given the results from Elders and Incitec Pivot

[held]

Read More
#Management
stale
Added 2 years ago

Nice to see CEO Greg Hunt buying a fair chunk on market

I guess he is still confident on hitting those ambitious revenue forecasts.

2dadb20188682a3c3227a4d8d67f756fc68ece.png

f0fea7412789287f9987db4f6d5c420e87c914.png

[held]

Read More
#Bull Case
stale
Added 2 years ago

Bit of FOMO happening here although the GICs sector that Nufarm is a part of is rallying quite well.

eeab2dbcdd312279d30368f596a0c93f167a43.png

Apparently Nufarm is a chemical company even though they serve the Ag sector

Anyone brave enough to top up at the lows when Sumitomo Chemical sold out deserves a pat on the back although they were also underperforming too.

The fact debt hasn't reduced much is a bit worrying unless there is massive growth on the horizon (see previous straw)

[held]


Read More
#Bull Case
stale
Added 2 years ago

Nufarm's results came in at a beat with a positive outlook up to FY26.

48e444035e05a5a411d98a247594679696217f.png

Increasing the dividend but not sure if that's a good idea given the debt is 0.8x of EBITDA.

I would have kept dividend flat and pay off the debt unless they are bullish about growth prospects going forward which is hard to see given some of the extreme weather events having a negative impact on agriculture overall.

Still holding considering the previous on market purchase from the CEO during the selldown from Sumitomo where no participated in the bookbuild.

[held]

Read More
Valuation of $6.40
stale
Edited 3 years ago

From Livewire

https://www.livewiremarkets.com/wires/have-you-got-enough-food-in-your-bunker

We most recently re-entered NUF in October 2021 when the stock was trading at ~AUD4.50/share or ~80% of book value, which compares to our current DCF derived valuation of ~AUD6.40/share (WACC10%).

There are 2 key points with our valuation that we point out

a) It includes a heavily risked valuation for Nuseed, that we suspect will derisk over time

b) We have discounted the whole business at the same cost of capital however we believe ultimately the Nuseed business deserves to trade at a higher multiple given the proprietary nature of technology and stronger growth potential than the core crop protection business.

My notes: I've noticed lots of off screen buying in the last few days and "manipulation" of the sell side perhaps to create a diversion from potential buyers? Anyway I bought IRL at $6. Seems like a good turnaround play.

Read More
Valuation of $6.50
stale
Added 5 years ago
Refer to my notes under "BULL CASE"
Read More
Valuation of $5.55
stale
Added 6 years ago
Assumes return to historical valuation levels 9x EV/EBITDA (still 25% lower than market average). At low end of guidance, this implies an SP of $9.02. Post HY19 result, negative momentum in the operating business in place. Assuming mid-point EBITDA of $455m and lower end of historical multiple of 7x, target price drops to $5.55. Whilst still 27% upside is greater, it'll really be cheap when the business's fundamentals are inflecting and can re-rate to higher end of historical ranges.
Read More