26-Jan-2020. Happy Australia Day everybody! I've just posted a "Bull Case" straw for Resolute Mining (RSG), an ASX-listed gold producer who are soon going to have their mines and operations 100% in West Africa (apart from offices in Perth and London).
Apart from the gold-price risk that comes with owning shares in any gold miner, the company-specific risks associated with owning RSG shares, as I see them, are mostly:
Debt: RSG are currently in the process of raising US$135m (A$196m) via Placements and an SPP (which will be open during February for existing shareholders to each buy up to $30k of new RSG shares @ A$1.10/share - RSG closed on Friday [24-Jan-20] at $1.17), which will be used to fully repay the Taurus bridging loan facility that was put in place to enable RSG to acquire Toro Gold last year (and the Mako mine). However, this potentially reduces their net debt from A$387m to A$191m, and $191m is still a significant amount of debt, particularly when a number of our larger ASX-listed gold miners have comparable costs and produce just as much gold but with zero net debt. The ones who do have net debt generally have lower gearing than RSG.
Sovereign risk: All of their mines are going to be in West Africa which is a riskier place to mine than Australia; While we can have unexpected policy (and tax/royalty/levy) changes here in Oz, most would argue that Indonesia, the Philippines, parts of South America and much of Africa is a lot riskier and a lot more unpredictable. It should be noted that Resolute have mitigated some of that risk. For instance, with 10% of their Mako mine in Senegal being owned by the Senegal Government (who also receive royalties of between 3% and 5% - currently 5% - of all gold sales), they have a very supportive shareholder and stakeholder in the Senegalese Government. However, people can get greedy sometimes and want more of a good thing - as a number of Australian mining companies who operate overseas have found out. Agreements can be renegotiated, leases come up for review periodically, licences to operate can also be reviewed or modified at times. Things happen. And they tend to happen more O/S than they do here in Oz - in my experience.
Currency Risk: All of RSG's revenue from their African gold mines is received in US$, not A$, but then the bulk of their costs are also in US$ so there is some mitigation there against the currency exposure. It is still worth noting that RSG do pay dividends in A$, and if the US$ depreciates against the A$ (or, looking at it the other way, if the A$ appeciates against the US$) then RSG's profits from their US$ African mines will be worth less in A$'s.
Business Plan/Execution Risk: Firstly, I can understand what RSG are trying to do. They're selling Ravenswood, which had the highest AISC of their 4 mines, and Bibiani (in Ghana) is under review, and could also be sold. I expect they will try to offload Bibiani to further reduce their debt. However, things don't always go to plan. Also, the deal with selling Ravenswood to a consortium comprising specialist resources private equity group, EMR Capital, and Singapore-listed energy and resources company, Golden Energy and Resources, has been touted as "Resolute will receive cash proceeds of up to A$300 million", however the breakdown of that is:
- A$100 million of upfront proceeds consisting of A$50 million of cash and A$50 million in promissory notes;
- Up to A$50 million linked to the average gold price over a four-year period (gold price contingent payment); and
- Up to A$150 million linked to the investment outcomes of Ravenswood for the EMR Fund (upside sharing payment).
As you can see, not much of that $300m is being paid upfront, and the rest is conditional and will take a number of years to eventuate (if indeed it does eventuate). I'm not sure that is such a great deal for RSG for a mine that has more than 10 years of mine life left, a 5.9 Moz Mineral Resource, a 2.7 Moz Ore Reserve, a LOM AISC of US$823/oz (A$1,193, with the current spot gold price being almost double that), and a 5 Mtpa processing plant (larger than Syama, Mako or Bibiani).
If you want exposure to West African gold production via a decent-sized ASX-listed company, there is really only RSG and PRU - Perseus Mining - with their Edikan gold mine in Ghana, and their two gold mines in Côte d’Ivoire, Sissingué and Yaouré. PRU's SP has risen +193% (from 38c to $1.115) in the past 11 months so you can certainly make money with these companies when things do go right for them, but go in with your eyes wide open, knowing the risks.
Personally I prefer goldies who have the majority of their mining operations here in Australia, and I currently hold shares in NST, SAR, EVN and SBM with much smaller positions in PNR and RVR (RVR are diversifying into gold, but mostly mine zinc). I recently sold out of IGO who own 30% of the high-grade Tropicana gold mine in WA. I also like to play the better service providers to the gold industry.