Telstra is a business facing considerable challenges, but is far from terminal.
The structural change bought about by the nbn, and the competitive pressures that has unleashed, threatens to further erode margins. Earnings will take a further hit when one-off nbn payments cease in a few years.
Nevertheless, improving productivity and significant capital investments -- particularly into 5G -- could go a long way in plugging the gap.
This is a question of whether or not you believe management can deliver on the newly announced startegy: Telstra 2022. Something that promises to make Telstra a more competitive, efficient and focused operation.
If Mr Penn’s new strategy bears fruit, and (critically) if all cost savings are fully realised, you can make the case for value. Even if the dividend is cut in the meantime.
Some further thoughts here