Straws are discrete research notes that relate to a particular aspect of the company. Grouped under #hashtags, they are ranked by votes.
A good Straw offers a clear and concise perspective on the company and its prospects.
Please visit the forums tab for general discussion.
Just saw the news this morning that EVS are merging their water products in under Industrial.
While I can see the synergies from a GtM perspective and hopefully they have a reduced cost of sale overall, it will be a shame not to be able to track Water's growth independently of the other product lines.
Albeit off a small base, my investment thesis has been that Water is the wildcard in the portfolio with potentially very large growth driving the future of this business.
I caught the first half of Envirosuite's presentation, but had to duck away before the Q&A.
General vibe is that it felt very scripted, and Jason can come across quite salesy.
The numbers themselves were decent, not spectacular. EVS is a business that does seem to be grinding forward, just not at the clip I initially thought might have been achievable. Still, they are tantalisingly close to break even, a milestone that seems to always be just 6 months away...
Good to see gross margins improve, and the focus on better quality revenue seems to be paying off a bit, without sacrificing too much top line growth. (Although more site and revenue growth would be nice)
They are dropping the 'adjusted EBITDA' metric, which excludes share based comp, one-off restructure etc and will be reporting straight EBITDA going forward. This was negative $200k in the half.
The more telling operating cash flow was minus $1.8 million, though there's a sizeable working capital adjustment due to receivables from invoices issued at the end of the half, and an inventory build-up to support expected sales. Normalised for that op CF sits much closer to EBITDA at -$300k.
But if you add back capitalised development costs, which I think is appropriate, and am glad they call this out, cash flows were -$4.5m. And I think the market will be much more concerned with seeing this metric go positive, as opposed to just EBITDA.
ARR growth was (as already reported) pretty ordinary due to a 'strategic rationalisation' of low margin contracts, but the new ARR run rate is at about $9m for the last 12 months. If they add that again this year with minimal churn we would see a good return to growth. Moreover, given the gross margin, it'd essentially put them on a CF+'ve footing. Or at least get pretty close.
According top Jason today: ."we are confident on our ability to achieve a positive Adjusted EBITDA result less Capitalised Development costs on a run rate basis during FY24.”
So we'll see.
The company is reasonably well capitalised, with $5m cash and bunch of undrawn lending capacity. I think a further raise in unlikely, and management know it wouldn't be well-received at present. (But I wouldn't be surprised if they wanted to shore up the balance sheet at some stage if sentiment and share price improves.)
So the big IF here for me is whether they can indeed build up some more revenue momentum and support operations without much change in the fixed cost base. The second half is traditionally their strongest, so will be interesting to see how they go.
You can read up on some of the operational updates in their presentation
Held.
Latest sales update looks promising
https://envirosuite.com/insights/news/fy24-q2-sales-update
I’ll be interested to understand how much of these new sales are the “sell through” PPE (that I seem to recall was going to grow with debt funding) vs higher margin software revenue. I’ll be interested to see this when they publish their first half results which are supposed to be out in late February.
Inside Ownership Ordinary Shares Net Value at $0.09
Jason Cooper 1,150,000 $103,500
David Johnstone 7,033,016 $632,971
Sue Klose 1,000,000 $90,000
Stuart Bland 650,194 $58,517
Colby Manwaring 272,846 $24,556
Total 10,106,056 $909,545
*Note Inside Ownership of % of total share below 1% of total shares on issue so not included in table above.
Summary Management Bio from EVS webpage.
Jason Cooper – Managing Director & CEO
Mr. Cooper joined Envirosuite in July 2020 as chief operating officer, was appointed as Chief Executive Officer in March 2021 and appointed Managing Director March 2022. Since joining Envirosuite, Mr Cooper has been instrumental in driving the strategy for the Company during the backdrop of the COVID-19 pandemic. In this time, he finalised the integration of the major acquisition, commercialised EVS water nationally and internationally while driving growth across all product lines and regions.Jason is a highly regarded and well-respected industry leader with more than 20 years’ experience in the technology sector. He has had broad experience working in senior executive roles in both multi-national and start-up environments. During his career he has held senior roles across sales, operations and general management in the Silicon Valley, London, and Melbourne. Jason holds an executive MBA in Entrepreneurship and Innovation from HEC, France.
https://www.asx.com.au/asxpdf/20220223/pdf/4568f802457f05.pdf
https://www.asx.com.au/asxpdf/20210226/pdf/44t454mg5smsvq.pdf
David Johnstone – Non Executive Chairman
David is an experienced executive and chairman who has been actively involved in business for more than 35 years, successfully starting, owning and operating a vast range of businesses. David joined the Board as a non-executive Director in February 2014 and was appointed Chairman in September 2016.David also Chairs Cooper Investors, a specialist equity investor group with in excess of $12bn in funds under management, and Sports Club HQ a technology company that specialises in managing the Registration and Competition Management data requirements for Sporting clubs and associations. David is also a non-executive director of Southern Cross Partners and is an Advisory Board Member to NexPay. David has also served as both a director, non-executive director, Chair and advisor to both public and private companies in the technology, communications, finance, wealth management, insurance, risk management and sporting sectors.
Sue Klose – Non-executive Director
Sue Klose is an experienced non-executive director and executive, with a diverse background in digital business growth and operations, corporate development, strategy and marketing. Sue was previously the Head of Digital and Chief Marketing Officer (CMO) of GraysOnline and Director of Digital Corporate Development for News Ltd.
She is currently a non-executive director of Nearmap (ASX: NEA), Pureprofile (ASX: PPL), Halo Food Co. (ASX: HLF) as well as a number of unlisted groups.
Sue has an MBA in Finance, Strategy and Marketing from the JL Kellogg School of Management at Northwestern University, and a Bachelor of Science in Economics from the Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania.
Stuart Bland – Non-executive Director
Stuart has over 30 years’ broad commercial experience primarily in global SaaS businesses undergoing high rates of growth. His industry experience includes technology (fintech, knowledge management), defence, sport, telecommunications, biotechnology and wine.
Stuart’s executive experience includes 14 years as Chief Financial Officer at Iress Ltd (ASX:IRE) and Chief Financial Offer roles at Melbourne IT Ltd and Panviva Pty Ltd. Stuart is currently a member of the Advisory Board to Cablex Pty Ltd, as well as consulting to a number of other Boards.
Colby Manwaring – Non-executive Director
Colby is an experienced board member and executive with a proven track record of driving growth in technology companies in Australia, UK, Spain, and several USA locations. Colby’s most recent executive roles included CEO of multi-national infrastructure analytics software company, Innovyze, which subsequently sold to software giant Autodesk in 2021 for $1Bn USD ($1.55Bn AUD), where he continued as a Vice President. Colby has successfully aligned organic growth initiatives to product and people resources to deliver balanced growth and profitability outcomes. He has also led buy-side and sell-side M&A initiatives for six businesses, in addition to advising on due diligence and integration planning of over 30 others. Colby is a licensed Professional Engineer and holds a BS and MS in Civil and Environmental Engineering from Brigham Young University, as well as a Minor of Engineering Business Administration from the Brigham Young University Marriott School of Management.
In the afr today...
Smith also likes air pollution and noise monitoring software provider Envirosuite. Its enterprise value is just one times its annual sales, and Smith says it’s the market leader in its space.
“It’s just in profitability for its mining and airports businesses, but there’s a water business losing money, so the water losses are distracting the market, but that’s easily fixed,” he says.
Envirosuite held a webinar today after their AGM. The recording will be available on their website soon.
Nothing much new really, although Jason did mention they expect to hit $100m in ARR in the not too distant future (they are at $60m at present). I pressed him on this in the Q&A, and he didn't want to commit to a timeframe. He also said that achieving profitability was the primary focus at this stage, but that $100m was "in sight".
Someone asked when they expected to hit positive EPS and he said they didn't want to commit to anything just yet, but that they may make an announcement in the coming year. The intention it seems is "soon", but i'll be happy enough with a decent momentum in positive cash flows.
Overall, the messaging is that they have sustained growth, while transitioning to a more sustainable financial footing, and are experiencing good tailwinds in all geographies and sectors. Aviation, in particular, is showing some good signs of life as customers come out the other side of Covid. Regulation and ESG factors are big drivers, and this is true also for all segments. Water remains the potential "moon shot" within the business -- the target market is certainly massive, but time will tell if we see any sustained traction.
The share price seems insanely low if you put any stock in what management are saying. And, I suppose, given the company is currently valued at $78m, you can infer that the market doesn't currently hold a huge amount of faith.
Frankly, one of my biggest concerns is the lack of any material inside ownership. If the opportunity is so great, you'd think senior management and the board would be tipping in some of their hard earned money.
For better or worse, I remain a bruised but optimistic shareholder. So long as ARR continues to march upwards, ideally with some acceleration, and if they not only sustain positive cash flows but also deliver expanding operating margins, then I'm staying the course.
Last week I sent emails to Envirosuite, Pointerra & Kogan asking them in this day and age, why couldn't they include virtual attendance at their AGM.
Envirosuite replied very promptly, saying that they provided virtual attendance at their AGM's during Covid but it proved not to be very popular, but they would consider it for next year.
Well, it looks like they've brought that consideration forward as they are providing a virtual presentation with Q&A on Wednesday 29th 3pm (AEDT).
The recording will be available on their website afterwards if you're not able to dial in.
As for Pointerra & Kogan, I'm still waiting for an email response.
I was a previous holder of EVS however sold out some time ago based on disappointing revenue growth and an apparent inability to control growth in expenses. I have not followed EVS since.
I followed the forum post link by @Remorhaz and watched @Strawman call EVS a buy.
I thought it best to go back and take another look at EVS.
Revenue growth FY23/FY22 8.3%.
Loss before tax has remained in the -$11M to -$12M range since 2021.
Q1FY24 ARR growth 10%.
The Q1FY24 Outlook Statement (below) was as vague as they come:
So, after adjusting the EBITDA and capitalising expenses and based and the exit ARR for FY24 they should be cash flow positive.
They had $8.2M cash at 30 June 2023. Capitalised development costs of $5.8M in FY23 increasing at 55.4% pa over 2 years. The cash balance will get very slim unless they can cut costs or greatly increase revenue.
My valuation model indicates EVS as currently overvalued.
I don’t see EVS as a company you need to be invested in at present. There will be plenty of time to jump in later if they manage to improve the financials.
Not a terrible result from Envirosuite. I missed the first part of the briefing this morning, but my main thoughts are (starting with the negative):
The company has a market cap that is only 10% above its annual recurring revenue (It's a flawed metric, but you have to work with what you've got!). The near term working capital demands are no longer threatening a raise, we're seeing new customers and a reasonable level of growth in recurring revenues, as well as a large opportunity across the three divisions. It's a super niche area, but one in which EVS is the global leader.
Yeah, it hasn't executed as well as I'd have liked, and they got over their skis for a time there in terms of cost management and growth initiatives, but they've got a good offering across various sectors that all appear to have some traction.
I'm continuing to hold. I wouldn't call EVS a high quality company (although that potential exists for the future), but the valuation seems compelling.
FY24 Q1 SALES UPDATE
$3.7m Sales up 9% on PCP,
Company ARR grows 10% on PCP to $60.6m
Key Highlights:
ASX RELEASE
6 October 2023
Funding facility secured to support growth
Highlights:
Limit Interest rate Term Purpose
$7.5m
The greater of the 3 month BBSW rate plus 7.75% pa and 11.75% paii
3 years from 5 October 2023
Growth and working capital in the normal course of business, including funding trade finance and equipment finance investments
The terms of the Facility are summarised in Annexure A in this announcement – see overleaf – aside from which there are no further material items that need to be satisfied or approved prior to drawdown.
Authorised for release by the Board of Envirosuite Limited.
For further information contact: Adam Gallagher
Company Secretary
E: adam gallagher@envirosuite.com M: +61 428 130 447
1 Envirosuite Limited Level 30, 385 Bourke St
Melbourne VIC 3000
(ASX: EVS) ACN: 122 919 948 www.envirosuite.com Phone: (02) 8484 5819
ABOUT ENVIROSUITE
Envirosuite (ASX: EVS) is a global leader in environmental intelligence and is a trusted partner to the world’s leading industry operators in aviation, mining & industrial, waste and water.
Envirosuite combines leading-edge science and innovative technology with industry expertise to produce predictable and actionable insights, that allows customers to optimise their operations, remain compliant and manage their environmental impact.
By harnessing the power of environmental intelligence, Envirosuite helps industries grow sustainably and communities to thrive.
www.envirosuite.com
Colby Manwaring to be appointed as Director
'Colby has had an executive and entrepreneurial career in water and environmental software, covering nearly all aspects of the industry, including software development, sales and marketing, professional technical training, strategic business planning and execution, mergers and acquisitions, and strategic alliances. Starting his career as a software developer he went on to lead multi-national infrastructure analytics software company, Innovyze, with 3,000 customers globally, which subsequently sold to software giant Autodesk in 2021 for $1Bn USD ($1.55Bn AUD).'
Interesting that Colby is a) based in North America, EVS' largest region and b) has a background in water.
Colby was CEO when Innovyze was sold to Autodesk for just over $1b in 2021. Prior to this, he spent 10 years as CEO of XP Solutions -- another US based business -- which was eventually merged with Innovyze in 2017. Innovyze is a global leader in water infrastructure software. When the acquisition took place, Autodesk stated it positioned them 'as a technology leader in end-to-end water infrastructure solutions from design to operations, accelerates Autodesk’s digital twin strategy, and creates a clearer path to a more sustainable and digitized water industry.'
Very, very interesting. Colby will presumably add significant value and subject-matter expertise around the water segment and bring an established network with him to the director role.
Hugh Robertson to step down
Having served as a director since September 2018, Hugh will step down effective 1 September 2023. There is no justification given for his exit. On paper though, Colby seems a much better addition to the board, so I am not complaining..
My meeting notes for the August 2023 interview:
disc: Held IRL.
Another good meeting. My notes are below:
As always, it is great to hear a CEO in the Smiling @Strawman Starchamber.
My takeaway from the discussion is that Jason has been pretty consistent over the three meetings, and I certainly share his disappointment at the lack of a positive response to the annual results, which were good.
However, $EVS remains on my watchlist for now, because I want to see some further confirmation of the ARR growth / revenue trajectory. Because of the huge, global, macro-theme around its ESG-aligned offerings, one thing holding me back is that I don't understand the competitive dynamics in its three verticals. For sure, customers are investing in all three areas, so at some point we have to see a more material uptick in sales.
In concept, $EVS might become a Baby Giant, so I remain interested. And, indeed, the FY23 post-COVID recovery in ARR-uplift is a positive sign that there is more than a story here.
I'm all done with numbers for this week, so instead I will use an analogy to try and convey my assessment.
I'm standing on the 5th floor of a skyscraper (>100 floors), with a row of elevators (ride opportunities) in front of me and a dozen passengers I have to direct to queue at each door to ride to the top. As I see each elevator rising up from the 3rd or 4th floor, I direct each passenger to wait at the door to board the lift. There are several other elevators already moving up to my floor, but I can't see when the $EVS "elevator" is going to arrive, as it is still down at the 1st or 2nd floor. So, I am directing my passengers ($$) to those doors where I've got the confidence they won't have to wait too long. (In my analogy, the payoff is bigger if you get on at lower floors, but is reduced if the elevator is too slow - if that wasn't clear).
OK, not sure if that works. But it is how I am reading things.
Disc: Not held in RL or SM
Our meeting with Envirosuite CEO Jason Cooper this week is well timed; no doubt we'll have some good questions for him and he'll be able to speak much more candidly now their numbers have been published.
(BTW -- please add any questions for Jason here)
First off, the ARR results were known following their 4th quarter results . As mentioned at the time, these were pretty good thanks to a record 4th quarter.
Annual ARR growth in recent years has been:
FY20: (not relevant as the acquisition of EMS distorts things. fwiw ARR in 2019 was $5.6m, which at least points to the substantial growth of the industrials segment)
FY21: 8.1%
FY22: 14.0%
FY23: 12.1%
It's worth noting that the industrial segment ARR growth has been around 22%pa over the last 3 years. With airports no longer (hopefully) acting as a deadweight, we'll see group ARR accelerate a bit.
If EVS simply match the same new ARR in the current year, total group ARR should be up by over 15% for FY24. Which is about what's needed as a minimum for me.
(The water segment is still very nascent -- but a bit of traction here could really help too. I'm really looking at this as a free kick option right now)
This time last year, ARR was reported at $53m, and for the year just ended EVS said it had recorded $49.5m in recurring revenue. There was the loss of those defence sites in the second half, but there was also $4m in new ARR from the first half -- so i'm not exactly sure why there's a small mismatch. A question for Jason, maybe just timing issues?
(It's not a huge difference, but ARR metrics just always seem to be a little fuzzy. Yes, a useful guide for investors and management, but too subjective for my liking)
Finally, it's great to see some really strong ARR growth in the Americas and EMEA. These are big markets, of course, so hopefully they can sustain some momentum in these geographies.
Anyway, moving past ARR.
It was good to see improved gross margins. In fact they've been steadily improving for some time now. Tick.
Adjusted EBITDA was positive $500k, a big improvement from the $3.9m loss in FY22 and ahead of what they had guided for. The big swing factor here is the $1.8m in annualised cost savings due to restructuring efforts (ie redundancies), which is reasonable to strip out, imo. Less so is the exclusion of share based payments, which amounted to $743k -- add that back in and it was a negative adjusted EBITDA.
To be fair, they do breakout a better picture of things with what they call "Management Operating Cash flow":
So not to be negative (I'm certainly not unhappy with the improved trajectory with the financials), but the business is very much asking you to focus on their preferred metrics. Let's not forget that on a statutory basis they lost over $10m this year -- largely due to $9.4m in D&A charges.
In fact, capitalised development costs were up 21.3% to $5.7m. And accounting for this, operating cash flows were negative $3m (even if you add back one-off restructuring costs and the like). Still, they have been working on new modules and there's (hopefully) genuine value being created. And, yes, capitalising dev costs is just par for the course -- even Objective Corp has yielded to the practice! Still, i just make note of it. Those D&A charges may be "non-cash" but they are very real if you hope to maintain competitive software solutions.
There's a little over $8m in cash left. So it'll be a close call with a raise. Prudence suggests it's wise to expect one. Maybe they'll do a Pointerra and issue a big contract win first? (or maybe i'm just getting too cynical with age..)
Elsewhere, operating expenses were up 6.9% over the year to over $40m (see annual report, not the preso, for stat numbers). I'm keen to see what the 'normalised' cost base is like. The truth is, we need to see some operating leverage kick in -- and if they can sustain 16% gross profit growth while holding fixed costs steady (or at least only wear modest fixed cost growth), 'adjusted EBITDA' could really explode higher -- and even, dare i say it,NPAT growth too -- in the coming years.
Anyway -- there's a solid little business somewhere here. Overly aggressive expansion plans (remember the push into China?), ill-disciplined cost control, a global pandemic that knocked the biggest segment for six, a change in management...(have i missed anything?).. have all acted to impede the growth in cash flows and certainly tested shareholder patience. But i'm encouraged with the return of growth in aviation, the continued strong growth in industrial segment and the free kick potential with water (the Chairman has said this segment has the potential to be the "jewel in the crown"), especially in combination with more prudent cost discipline.
If all goes well, I cant see why Envirosuite shouldn't be generating $100m in revenue in 3-4 years. Ideally with at least a 20% operating margin. If achieved, the market cap could easily be $200-250m (around 16-20cps) at that stage, and offer a decent annual return for current investors.
An overly dilutive raise, mediocre top line growth or a failure to manage costs effectively would, of course, undermine any confidence here.
Will continue to ponder and hoping we can get a clearer picture after we chat with Jason this Thursday.
[HELD]
Just went down a rabbit hole on the latest annual report ... (trying to work out my latest valuation)
Trying to work out the negative cashflow -8.052M and get a feel for when these guys are going to run out of money and need to raise more capital. They've only got 8.22M cash so look to have less than a year or runway left. Based on their last raise and burn I'm guessing they are going to be looking for another $10m or so which would be a further 10ish% dilution.
In doing this digging I realised how large an amount of goodwill they have on their balance sheet. In viewing this, they have racked up 66m of retained losses to generate 107m of intangible assets. This seems to be backed up by a DCF model from management.
My key question here is how do these figures compare with those in your DCFs or estimates of value (mid teens revenue growth rate with 12.5% discount rate) that seem to have lead to a consensus valuation of 15c per share?
FY23 FINANCIAL RESULTS
$4.5m improvement in Adjusted EBITDA to $0.5m profit, cash flow positive of $0.7m from operating activities, ARR grows to $59.4m up 12% YOY
Key Highlights:
Envirosuite had some decent numbers for the 4th quarter of FY23.
Full announcement here
Highlights:
EVS reiterated its target for "adjusted EBITDA profitability" for FY24. That was negative $500k at the half, at which point they had just under $12m in cash.
Shares are on about 1.9x ARR. If the underlying growth can be sustained anywhere near the quoted 20% level, and if they can realise some decent operating leverage (there's been some tentative progress here), then shares are probably good value.
There's a briefing at 10:30am AEST if anyone's interested (click here)
Disc: held
Not quite the $50k Strawman was chasing however Susan Klose picked up 500,000 shares today. Always happy to see director buying but feel the dial won’t turn until there is an announcement that they are getting closer to cashflow positive. Certainly requiring lots of patience.
Noting two on market purchases for Envirosuite directors recently.
CEO Jason Copper and outgoing Chairman David Johnstone picked up $10-12k worth each at about 8c/share.
It's always nice to see insiders buying on-market with their own funds, but if I were cynical i'd say it feels more about market signalling than simply the private investment decisions of Jason and David.
These are tiny transactions. Jason is on a fixed salary of $363k, plus 50% extra under a STI. As far as I know, this is his first on-market purchase (the current 1m shares held were granted as part of his remuneration package). I mean, great to see him buying on-market, but $12k is pretty weak.
David already owns close to 7m shares, so it's not going to move the dial either way. It is a nice sign given his intention to step down later this year, but would have been better if it was a more meaningful swing of the bat.
I'm probably nit picking here, and not suggesting any grand conspiracy at all. But if this were purely about directors buying shares because they consider them cheap, then at least make it worthwhile for your own sake. It's like me picking up an extra $500 worth -- what's the point?
If part of the rationale was to show confidence to investors, which is what it feels like, then such tiny amounts ain't going to do it.
I don't pretend to know their personal financial situations, but had we seen transactions of at least $50k or more, i'd take more notice.
Envirosuite is getting pounded pretty hard on tax loss selling. Quickly approaching 5 year lows.
Speaks to the sentiment investors have towards the business at the time. Board renewal will now likely align with investors holding renewal.
The Chairman David Johnstone is stepping down and the company is planning on renewing the board, although to what extent is not clear.
As of August 2022, the board looked like this:
David has served as the Chair for almost 7 years and has been with the company since 2014. Back then, shares were 7c each and the company was called Pacific Environment. It was a fair bit smaller then, generating $12m in revenues BUT far more profitable with $1.3m in NPAT.
At the time, it was largely an environmental engineering consulting firm and they were still developing the software side of the business. They subsequently sold the consulting arm and focused entirely on the SaaS offering.
Today, it has over $57m in annual revenue and no profit. But at the same time, shares on issue have grown 12x (so sales per share have gone backwards). Retained losses on the balance sheet have also ballooned $50m from 2014 levels.
The market cap has grown from $7m to $110m, but the share price has increased from 7c to 9c since 2014, (passing through 29c along the way when the SaaS growth narrative was running hot).
This is a good example of a company that has gotten a lot bigger, but hasn't delivered much value for long-term shareholders -- at least so far. A great reminder that growth can be very expensive and not always value accretive to shareholders.
Of course, that was then, this is now. While it's taken nearly a decade to transform the business, it does now have much more reliable revenues, top line growth is much stronger, the market opportunity larger and the (potential) economics better.
But given the long and winding journey, why would you be leaving now, just when breakeven is in sight and there's some momentum in sales?
David has about 7m shares (0.5% of the total company) so maybe the larger shareholders have initiated this? The Omerod family still control a stake (i think about 2.5%) but Ellerston Capital is the main shareholder with a 7.9% stake, and have been increasing their stake over the last year or so -- maybe they have been agitating for change? (fwiw, their micro cap fund has outperformed since inception)
I remain of the view that there is a solid little business somewhere here -- but it's also true that the capital management hasn't been great (I've never been a fan of the reverse takeover of the Airports business), and like a lot of tech growth companies, costs could have been better managed. The newish CEO Jason Cooper has been only been on board for about a year, so cant really lay much blame at his feat.
Worth also noting that Tim Ebbeck was only on the board for 6 months before leaving to "focus on other commitments". A very short stint.
Of the other directors, the longest serving is Hugh Robertson who has been there since 2018 and easily holds the most shares out of all board members (22m shares). The others have relatively insignificant holdings and have been there for 1-3 years.
Anyway, today's news could be good or bad depending on how you look at it.
Is this a change that is badly needed to bring in more experienced and capable directors? Ones that will enable EVS to better realise its potential?
Or is it a sign of disunity? Or a lack of conviction in the future from someone who has been on the inside for almost a decade?
It's virtually impossible to know from the outside, but on balance I think it'll be good to see a change. No offense to David, but he's had almost ten years, and the execution hasn't been fantastic.
ASX Announcement
Board succession planning for FY24
29 May 2023 - Leading environmental intelligence technology company, Envirosuite Limited (ASX: EVS) (Envirosuite or the Company) is pleased to advise the commencement of a planned board renewal process that is expected to complete by the end of H1 FY24
At the commencement of the process, the longest-serving member of the Board David Johnstone has advised that he intends to step down from the role of Chairman at or by the 2023 Annual General Meeting subject to a suitable successor joining the board
Chairman, David Johnstone said,
"It has been a privilege to lead the board through so many years and significant events and see the Company grow into the leading international environmental technology company that it is today. The business is now at a scale and juncture where we are attracting significant commercial and corporate opportunities globally
Similarly, our positioning has attracted potential board candidates with the talent, industry knowledge and experience to lead and support the executive team in the next stage of our growth and by opening the Chair role I want to ensure that the strength of the Company and its prospects continues to be reflected in the board”
The Company expects to make further announcements on its board renewal process in due course
I don't really have experience with how these things normally work so unsure whether to take this at face value or a euphemism for something more sinister?
DISC: Held in SM & RL
Commented on them alongside 4 other reports in my Substack this week.
Short thoughts:
Thinking about the churn deeper, it would seem to me that the Department of Defence’s airports may be quite different to other commercial airports (the traditional Envirosuite client), so perhaps this can help explain the churn. The product may have been less fit for purpose for a Defence base. The fact that the world’s largest airport operator Aena expanded their contract may support my hypothesis.
In general though, the question mark on what potential future growth they can achieve remains. We see a lot of quarters coming in at $2M in new ARR, and with the base increasing, this can lead growth to the low teens soon.
There is potential here as always:
Let’s see how they go in full year results. In future years, the water segment’s growth will be interesting to monitor.
20 April 2023: MA Moelis Australia: Envirosuite Limited (Buy): "Mar'23 4C: ARR broadly flat due to Aviation churn, 4Q pipeline remains strong"
That's the first page. Click here to access the full report.
Disclosure: I hold EVS shares here in my Strawman.com virtual portfolio and also in one of my real life portfolios.
Envirosuite MA Moelis AU buy rec 20 April.pdf
Solid broker report with a "target price" of 17c. Touches on much of what has already been discussed.
@mikebrisy, agree that the ARR result was disappointing, but the reasons for this were clearly articulated, with EVS obviously losing a DOD contract. This was elaborated on in the call -- a Dutch company was favoured over EVS. This is disappointing (obviously) but management have downplayed it indicating defence is not their target market. Whether you want to believe this or not is one thing, but their past record suggests their product is actually quite sticky and they rarely have these major churn events so I think it is worth giving them the benefit of the doubt. In fairness to management, they didn’t run away from this, and they were transparent about what occurred.
You could also argue this was offset with the multi-year contract with Aena, the world’s largest airport operator by passenger volume – 12 airports for three years, adding 4.8m to ARR. They also added additional services, providing further validation.
Generally speaking, I actually thought the result was reasonably strong, with the exception of the DOD contract churn. With a market cap of under 150m, and trading on a P/S of 2.4x, they don't need to grow like the clappers as they aren't priced to do so. If they can achieve (or grind) 15-20% annual growth, and do this consistently for many years, they will be a sound long term investment. New project sales saw a nice rebound, with one of the stronger results in recent quarters, with 2.2m added. With Q4 traditionally EVS’ strongest quarter, and management continuing to reference a strong sales pipeline – particularly in aviation and mining – I expect a strong result in the next reporting period. Hopefully that one won't be impacted by a churn event!
Water remains the one to watch. Lots of promise, but they no traction/progress, at least in terms of revenue. They did report six customers going live in the reporting period. Management remains bullish on this sector, so I am expecting some results here over the next six months. Management was asked about delays on the call and indicated the worldwide aspect of their dealings – particularly when dealing with such big companies, many of whom aren’t used to SAAS – simply takes time. This still remains an unknown for investors, with several large Australian utilities still trialing SeweX. We likely won’t know for some time yet but there is lots of blue sky if they get it right. That said, if the trials don't amount to anything that would be a serious red flag for the water segment.
It was a good result for Omnis (now renamed Industrial, which makes sense) – strong sales and a reduction in churn. The Americas seems to be one to watch, with new US legislation allegedly driving demand. This contributed to over 50% of new ARR.
While the DOD churn is obviously disappointing, this reporting period is still consistent with the thesis. If the water segment can close some major contracts, that will be a bonus and a re-rate is likely to occur pretty quickly.
Disc - held
@raymon68 has provided the details on $EVS.
I only observe in addition that with New ARR of $2.0m in the Q - the same level achieved in the PCP - that Total ARR is moving into decline for the fist time in recent periods, from $56.9m to $56.2m. That's not what you expect in a growth play.
At the last investor presentation, Jason Cooper spoke powerfully about the quality of the pipeline and we were led to expect that there would be strong wins upcoming. However, I wasn't convinced, and exited at the time. Today's report indicates this questionmark remains.
I remain on the sidelines for now, with $EVS still on my watch list. This just isn't showing delivery progress commensurate with the story and earlier management rhetoric.
Disc: Not Held
EVS’ total ARR (annual recurring revenue) grew 15% in Q3 on pcp to $56.2m. Q3 new sales were $4.2m, up 14% on pcp. The company said it remains on track to achieve its target of transition to Adjusted EBITDA profitability during FY23.
EVS Aviation • Total ARR of $34.5m, up 8.5% on PCP (21% on PCP when excluding Australian DoD impact), with New ARR of $0.9m for the quarter.
• Abnormal churn increase in Q3 primarily due to the cessation of revenues for three of five sites currently contracted with Australian DoD. o Services going forward are for a different scope compared to the services that Envirosuite historically provided at these sites, and the services Envirosuite provides to other customers. o Envirosuite is contracted to provide services to the other two sites until at least FY25. o There was zero churn in Q3 aside from this in EVS Aviation.
• Multi-year €8.9m ($14.3m AUD TCV, $4.8m ARR) renewal and expansion of marquee European customer Aena, the world’s largest airport operator by passenger volume. Under the expanded agreement, Envirosuite will now provide its InsightFull community engagement solution at three major Spanish airports as part of Aena’s requirements under European Directive 2003/4/EC.
• New opportunities in China with a newly signed customer to be delivered with a local Chinese systems integrator, with several other opportunities in progress
This was a decent result for Envirosuite.
You can read all the details here, but the main things of note to me were:
Valuation remains undemanding at about 2.6x ARR (not a great measure, but somewhat useful as a benchmark at the current stage). Provided, that is, top line growth can be sustained (or exceeded) in the mid-teens AND the business scales well.
Held.
In answer to @Strawman 's question, overall the meeting commentary isn't adding much to the written release - beyond lots of positive talk about "opportunities" and "prospects", with lots of words like "huge" and "significant".
Both Jason and Justin stated that they see no need for a capital raise and that they remain on track towards profitability this year. Justin stated that he has a high focus on "contract-to-cash" to ensure the receipts flow.
There was some reference to their under-estimating procurement timescales on new deals. One reason cited was concern in Europe over energy costs. Based on the what was written and said, then H2 should be a very strong one for new sales. If it is not, then that would indicate that Jason is look at the business through rose-tinted spectacles.
They are very excited about the reported national airspace deal, as they think this is setting a new approach to how countries are looking at managing their airspaces. We'll see.
I agree with @Rocket6 's characterisation of progress at EVS as a "grind".
I have recently exited my RL holding at $0.135 in the belief that SP will not move materially until there is some demonstrated momentum. Of course, things can change quickly with one large deal or a strong quarter. I'd certainly be happy to jump back on board and EVS moves to my Priority Watch List.
I will align by SM position provided there isn't any SP deterioriation throught the day. (Which this post presumably doesn't help!)
Disc: Held on SM; Not Held in RL
Seems an ok quarter overall for Envirosuite. ASX announcement here
New ARR grew by 11% from a year ago. And total ARR up 16% to $56.9m, with Aviation recording its strongest quarter ever with air traffic rebounding in the US. The new carbon emissions module is showing some good potential.
That masked a drop in new ARR from Omnis, which added $0.6m in Q2 compared to $1.3m in the pcp. A number of deals were signed during the quarter with revenues expected in the current quarter. Overall Jason Cooper said he expects growth here to be at, or above, the historical growth rate for the rest of the year.
The nascent water business didn't see any new ARR (in total this segment is only at <2% of total ARR), but new features were released, previously signed contracts continued to be rolled out which, it's hoped, will provide useful reference sites and product validation. Combined with a proof of concept trial with a major US based water treatment services company, Jason reckons it provides the business with "an exceptional revenue opportunity"
Still have $12.9m in cash, down from $16.2 at June 30 last year, which implies an annual cash burn of $8.6m (although need to be careful here due to timing effects etc). I'm unable to attend the briefing today (register here for 10:30am), but it'd be good to get an update on how they see their cash burn evolving.
Overall, it seems the general thesis is on track. It's really encouraging to see some life in aviation after the impact of covid. Representing 70% of group revenues, previous sluggishness here has really limited overall growth.
While the level of total recurring revenue has been growing steadily -- the pace of growth hasn't improved for a while. EVS is adding an average of $8m in ARR per year, which represent mid-teen growth. Not bad, but it'd be nice to have all three segments increasing new ARR at the same time.
EVS shares are currently trading on 2.8x ARR
Held.
Catching up with quarterly reports, starting with EVS.
I have used the word ‘grind’ to describe EVS in the past, and this report is no different. In total, 2m of ARR was added in Q2, while new project sales were 1m.
It was a strong quarter for aviation – a record for the business in fact – with 1.4m added. This was somewhat fortunate, because Omnis growth was only 0.6; a disappointing result considering its strong last few quarters. Even worse, EVS Water recorded no ARR growth. That said, management notes that several major client ‘prospects’ approach final stages of due diligence, and are forecast to close in H2 FY23. They reference a POC with Evoqua Water Technologies, and three new SeweX sites being delivered to Watercorp in December 2022. They also note they have increased the speed at which SeweX can be deployed for new customers, and introduced new functionality for larger, more complex sewer networks. All good signs, but we need to see some of the alleged demand/pipeline converted into sales.
More broadly, we are told that ‘several large deals progressed to near completion in Q2 are anticipated to be signed in Q3. Based on this, Q3 should theoretically be a strong one.
Management provide us with some insight into cash burn. EVS ended FY22 with 16.2m in the bank, and we are told that cash on hand was 11.9m at the conclusion of H1. Based on this it appears cash burn (in H1) was around 4.3m.
On the face of it, H1 figures don’t look like they will be particularly impressive. We are still seeing steady enough growth – and small steps are clearly continuing to be taken in the Water and Omnis segments – but as with previous years the growth is more of a grind than bottom left to top right. Further, they are still churning through cash. I maintain that patience is required here, but I am looking to see an improvement in H2.
Registration for the Envirosuite Q2 FY23 Sales Update
Envirosuite Limited intends to host an investor briefing following the release of its Q2 FY23 Sales Update on Wednesday, 1 February 2023
The webcast briefing will be held at 10:30am AEDT and hosted by CEO, Jason Cooper and CFO, Justin Owen
Please register to join the webcast via this link: https://events.teams.microsoft.com/event/d1983326-5327-46c1-868e-d8abe40f9465@5597ad34-a305-4edb-8df7-696be8094b6d
Moelis Australia broker report on Envirosuite BUY rating with price target 0.17
https://mamoelisaustralia.bluematrix.com/sellside/EmailDocViewer?encrypt=6edd91b6-48ba-41dc-89fa-07bbfdbcd1c4&mime=pdf&co=moelis&id=edward.day@moelisaustralia.com&source=mail
Have announced achieving adjusted EBITDA positive in fy23. Path to being NPAT positive seems much further away. Note from tables below that that the book value of the intangibles didn't materially move from fy21 to fy22 even though they made $5m amortisation. This because they capitalised another $5M in software development.
They have an eye watering $108M intangibles on the balance sheet. $89M is goodwill that they aren't amortising at all. Perhaps that's ok. That leaves $19M to amortise without adding any more which seems unlikely since they are capitising software dev to get to the adjusted ebitda break even.
I just attended the EVS investor call for their Q1 FY23 results and my notes are below. Unfortunately I missed the first 5 minutes of the call.
There were some good questions with people in particular digging into the (small amount) growth in the water segment and the value of the SA Water deal and expansion in number of sites at Water Corp. Unfortunately they didn't really shed any further light on specifics but said they were really happy with how it was progressing in line with their “Land, Expand and Scale” strategy.
Q1 Earnings call notes:
Very happy with the results.
Churn low at 2.3%, when it does happen due to construction projects finishing up (still good relationship with the builder/construction companies) and government spending reduction.
Water
Added second Australian water utility, SA Water, for SeweX. On top of existing customer Water Corp.
Only one site/catchment currently but great opportunity to expand. In line with “Land, Expand and Scale” strategy
Utilities like to start with one site/catchment as a trial and see how they can use it before rolling out to other sites.
Water Corp has expanded the number of sites using SeweX but they wouldn’t say how many specifically.
From a technology standpoint, continuing to add new features.
Outlook:
Q1 strongest start EVS has ever had to a year. Demand only getting stronger.
Validation on the SewX opportunity via acquisition of Water Corp and SA Water. Actively talking to many other water utilities in Australia. Unique product in the market.
New RGM (Regional General Manager) for Europe, to focus and drive sales in that region.
Pathway to profitability on track.
Philippines office going well and able to attract skilled and quality employees.
Continuing to look at supply chain improvements. Signed new 3rd party contract manufacturers. Adding on capability and de-risking.
Transitioning to an adjusted EBITDA profitable position in FY23. Fully funded to reach profitability, don’t see any need to raise further capital.
Did not answer a question in the chat box on reaching statuatory profitability.
SGS partnership focused on Omnis product.
SGS active in so many segments around the world but starting focus on mining, industrial and oil & gas.
Philippine office not a “cost reduction” strategy, but “cost efficiency” way to grow at a lower marginal cost.
Putting like minded people in one environment. A centre of excellence.
@Rocket6 has already added excellent comments, so i just wanted to add one point from the investor call (i did miss most of it unfortunately)
They emphasised they would be 'adjusted EBITDA' positive this year and had no need to access the capital markets.
I'll also second the significance of the SGS partnership. Will be watching that with great interest.
On initial impression, this report isn’t nearly as impressive as their previous quarter (Q4 FY22, which was a belter). Q1 sales was a modest 3.4m, which pales in comparison to the 6m recorded in Q4. That said, there were some real positives.
Highlights
New contract win – SGS
This is a multinational company which provides world-leading inspection, verification, testing and certification services. With more than 90,000 staff, 2600 offices and a 2021 revenue of more than $6b (CHF), this appears an impressive ‘get’ for EVS.
So what exactly does the alliance consist of?
‘The agreement sets out terms that will see EVS and SGS work together collaboratively to promote, market, and sell bundled services that combine SGS’s testing, inspection, and certification services with the EVS Omnis environmental intelligence platform to provide complete compliance and operational optimisation solutions for companies in a range of sectors globally, including the mining, heavy industrial and oil & gas sectors.’
EVS anticipate the partnership – essentially the bundled services – will expand global market opportunities and accelerate revenue growth.
Yes, the expected revenue growth is excellent, but a company bringing in more than $6b per annum in revenue wanting to bundle their services with EVS (Omnis) suggests 1) EVS is clearly doing something right, and 2) confirms the unique point of difference Omnis provides. For SGS to sign this agreement, you would expect they are confident Omnis will provide strong value add for customers.
It is hard to gauge the impact this will have on EVS’s top line – and when we will see this occur – but I would have thought this is well and truly material for the business. In addition, it should provide EVS exposure to new geographical areas where they don't currently service; the beauty of bundling services with a global behemoth in their respective industry!
Product suite breakdown
More of the same for EVS. Again Omnis leads from the front – the agreement with SGS suggests to me this will be a common theme going forward. Some other points below:
I will tune into the investor presentation and report back with any significant commentary.
ASX ANNOUNCEMENT
Q1 Total Sales of $3.4m
$55.2m Total ARR up 13.6% PCP
$2.1m increase in new ARR up 23.5% PCP
Strategic alliance established with global leader Key Highlights:
WEBCAST
Investor Briefing Notification: Q1 Sales Update14 October 2022 - Envirosuite Limited (ASX: EVS) intends to host an investor briefing following the release of its Q1 FY23 Sales Update on Tuesday, 18 October 2022
The webcast briefing will be held at 10:30am AEDT and hosted by CEO, Jason Cooper and CFO, Justin Owen
Please register to join the webcast via this link: Envirosuite Q1 FY23 Sales Update
Questions from participants will be taken at the conclusion of the presentation. If you would like to submit a question at any time before or after the webcast, please email them to investors@envirosuite.com with the subject line: ‘Q1 FY23 Sales Update Q&A’
The recording will be made available on the Investor page of the Envirosuite website following the webcast
@mikebrisy already gave an excellent overview of Envirosuite's recent product demo, but there's a recording available on Youtube if you want to watch:
Post a valuation or endorse another member's valuation.